From Helena.Bialkowska@fuw.edu.pl Wed Jun  6 09:32:45 2012
Date: Wed, 6 Jun 2012 08:45:50 +0200 (CEST)
From: Helena Bialkowska <Helena.Bialkowska@fuw.edu.pl>
To: Marek Szuba <Marek.Szuba@kit.edu>
Cc: Bialkowska Helena <Helena.Bialkowska@fuw.edu.pl>, Gazdzicki Marek <Marek.Gazdzicki@cern.ch>, Laszlo Andras <laszloa@szofi.elte.hu>, Mitrovski Michael <Michael.Mitrovski@cern.ch>, Seyboth Peter <pxs@mppmu.mpg.de>
Subject: Re: Fourth draft of the azimuthal-correlation paper

Dear Colleagues,

Some comments on the new (very solid and informative) version of the 
azimuthal correlations paper.

1. Nowhere in the text it is said what is the rapidity range of the 
particles for which we study correlations.

2. In the introduction (page 3), discussion (page 21) and summary (page 
25)  triangular flow is invoked as a possible main culprit for the 
observed correlation behaviour. This is a bit too specific - in general,
these are initial state fluctuations that lead to the effects observed at 
RHIC (and - possibly - SPS), and triangular flow is just one of many 
manifestations/descriptions.

3. URQMD seems indeed to describe the data, also for the near side. Thus 
the statement about `depletion at deconfinement energy' is a bit strong...

Best regards,
Helena