https://edupad.ch/voHjii24XB

G4 logo meeting - 30th March 2017 -

Links :

    - All designs : https://g4logo-contest.github.io/Designs-all2.html

    - 4 finalists : https://g4logo-contest.github.io/Designs.html

    G4AI logo : Geant4MasterLogo-940.jpg

    Results : 

•  First vote : 72 votes

• 59 designs - 72 votes

• 9 votes : #43 :)

• 7 votes : #25

• 6 votes : #54

• 5 votes : #5

• 4 votes : #3 #52 #56

• 3 votes : #2 #13 #21 #26

• 2 votes : #7 #10 #12 #19 #23 #40 #48

• Second vote : 66 votes

• - Design 1 : 13

• - Design 2 : 17

• - Design 3 : 17

• - Design 4 : 18

• - Vote blanche : 2

Presents: All 7 except Marc (excuse)

Topics: 

• Revise and refine the requirements according to the 59 designs we already have (and don't like)

• Send the revised requirements to the four finalists and ask them to re-submit a logo

• If a suitable logo is received and selected by the committee then put it to the full collaboration for a graded vote (5 intervals) - values less than the mean are counted negative, so logo should be endorsed rather than simply the best of the worst. (last time "vote blanche" was hardly chosen despite a number of dissenters). 

General Guidelines

• "G" should be at the same level as "4". Message to pass: Geant4 is the name not Geant Version 4

• Number 56 is a way to go

• Transparent background is fine/better than white. With a box if the background is full

• G4 logo should not look the same as others of our institutionals logos (Ex SLAC? G4 AI...)

Color Scheme:

    2/3 colors ? Two many colors are confusing

    Finalists :

        1 - Stronger colours, tracks are a bit random and invisible on Geant4 one, more 4 to level of rest of text and same size, grey background. Some kind of detector behind. Police a bit too small. Tracks are confusing

        2 - Green/blue/brown green is too light, spiral has not link to Geant4 / simulation. Police is fine. Tracks are fine

        3 -  Some kind of detector behind, fragmented shape will not show up well when small. Spacing on each caracters is a bit too much. Police is a bit square. Tracks are too confusing

        4 - No meaning for the geometrical shape, bland colour scheme. Small logo is illisible

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazard_symbol#/media/File:WMD-chemical.svg

Banner size

    - Prefer the #56 sizing

    - Number 4 finalist is too much square

    - compatability with a favicon format

Slogan

    Geometry and tracking ? - no

    Radiation simulation toolkit ?

    Simulating Reality?

    A simulation toolkit ? <=

    Simulating Radiations ? - Radiation Simulation or no "s" Radiation(s) simulated ?

- Regroup requierements

- Send the requirements

- Final proposal : Skype meeting with them

Send a mail on finalists on 10th April

        Ask the finalists if they want to revise there logo according to your requirements. 4 finalists + a few others (number 56)