CTD2018 program committee

Europe/Zurich
Shih-Chieh Hsu (University of Washington Seattle (US))
    • 17:30 17:50
      Member composition of CTD 2018 international programm committee 20m

      CTD 2018 orgnaizaton notes

      https://docs.google.com/document/d/12ns82CXQi-eAqbt9yfFjgPPK_f1UZHiJrirBmc-ysJM/edit?usp=sharing

      New members nominations:

      • Are Strandlie, NTNU in Gjøvik, Norway - nominated by Rudolf Frühwirth
      • Andreas Salzburger, CERN (ATLAS)  - nominated by Markus Elsing

      CTD/WIT2017 members whom expressed interests to stay in the CTD2018 program committee

      • Rudolf Frühwirth, Austrian Academy of Sciences,  CMS
      • Martin Heck,  Karlsruhe, Germany (Belle II tracking conveners)
      • And others?

      Once CTD2018 program committee is formed. I'll set up new mailing list, spreadsheet of talks, and schedule kick-off meeting to populate spreadsheet. New committee will fix the date and also decide if we call for abstracts or have all talks by invitation only.
      Q: shall we meet in two weeks time scale for the CTD2018 kick-off meeting?

       

    • 17:30 17:50
      CTD2018 Program Committee Kick-off meeting 20m
      • Date
      • Request abstract
      • Poster session
      • Scientific Tracks
      • Do we want to assign committee members to each track?
      • Every committee member should propose at least 2 subjects by Sep 15
      • Next meeting time
        • Aug 29 or Sep 5
      • Milestone dates
        • Aug 15: 1st draft of website, poster
        • Sep 15: announce conference and release website for public
        • Oct 3: start inviting speakers
        • Nov 30: deadline for abstract submission  
        • Dec 19: end speaker invitation
    • 17:30 17:50
      plenary speakers 20m
      • Attendances: Andi, Markus, Eugenio, Fabrizio, Maurice, Michel, Richard, Rudi, Hsu

      • Agree on invited speakers

        • Accepted

          • No3. “HL-LHC PU mitigration strategy”
            Maurice will contact Simone Griso, Rudi will contact Lindsay Gray. We will discuss speakers in the next meeting

          • No9. “Fast reconstruction and data scouting”
            Speakers to be decided based on ATLAS/CMS balance

          • No12. “Status report from the HEP.TrkX Project”
            Rudi will discuss with the team to identify speakers

          • No17. “Online Multi-Target Tracking using Recurrent Neural Networks” Rudi will followup to identify speaker

          • No20. “Status of the ACTS tracking kit”
            SC will invite Moritz Kiehn

        • On-hold

          • No5. “Disconnecting th Graphs “
            SC will discuss with authors to clarify latest progress

          • No8. “GPU / CPU interplay in pattern recognition”
            Michel and Markus will define the scope and discuss in the next committee meeting.

          • No11. “Tracking challenge”
            Andi and Davide will coordinate this with hands-on session

          • No13. “End-to-end learning”
            There might be an abstract submission. If not, we will discuss invitations during abstract review.

          • No15. “Quantum Computing in the context of HL-LHC track pattern recognition”
            Questions to Paolo. We need clear guidelines and inputs about the scope of this talk so that it can be interesting to this community. What is the overlap to No.5 "disconnecting the Graphic"?

        • Non-HEP talk to be decided with high priority.

          • No6. “Deep Learning For Automatic Image-based Galaxy-Galaxy Strong Lens Finding”

          • No10. “Pattern recognition in GW interferometers”

          • No14. “Accelerating gravitation lensing image processing”

    • 17:30 17:50
      plenary talk reviews 20m
      • Not available today: Maurice, Markus, Alberto

      • Attendances: Andi, David, Fabrizio, Cecile, Martin, Michel, Paolo, Rudi, Hsu

      • Plenary speaker discussions

        • non-HEP talk

          • Fabrizio will discuss

          • SC will invite Philip J. Marshall

        • Follow-up actions

      • Tracking challenge to prepare more realistic hits data (previously, perfect cylinder geometry was provided.)

        • A talk?

        • Hands-on session?

      • The abstract submission deadline is Oct 31

        • Each member should contact each experiment/institute to submit abstract.

        • Could David share email template? Done.

      • Advertisement

        • Poster - make request here

      • Outreach event

        • Public talk - Carl Haber on restoring ancient sound with particle detector

      • Next meeting ?

        • Target number of plenary talks: 28 for 2.5 days + hackthon

        • Remaining proposed plenary talks will be reviewed together with submitted abstracts

        • Discussion extension (perhaps 1 week) on Oct 31

        • One week for committee review after extension of due days

        • Potential meeting date: Nov 22

    • 17:30 17:50
      Abstract review 20m
      • Participants: Alberto, Paolo, Rudi, Michel
      • Public lecture agenda discussion [spreadsheet]

        • Option1:

          • Mon (Mar 19) 7:00pm Public lecture - Carl Haber (Ancient Sound Restoration using Particle Tracker)

        • Option2 (agreed):
          • Tue (Mar 20) 7:30pm Public lecture - Carl Haber (Ancient Sound Restoration using Particle Tracker)

        • Other workshop Activities

          • Tue (Mar 20) 4:30pm~9:00pm TrackML hackthon

          • Tue (Mar 20) 5:30pm~7:00pm Reception

          • Wed (Mar 21) 7:00pm Dinner banquet

      • Registration

        • CTD2018 - 3 registered so far

        • TrackML hackathon - already setup by David. Thank you.

      • Committee proposal

        • 23 proposals

        • 6 accepted (20+10’) so far

          • NN strong lensing [Doodle]: Philip Marshal (declined)
            Poll results: Yashar Hezaveh (4) vs Siamak Ravanbaksch (3), I'll send invitations to Yashar.

          • HEP.TrkX speaker - wait for Paolo’s confirmation. Paolo suggested to put his name down.

      • Submitted abstract  

        • 23 submissions so far (3 of them overlap to Committee proposal)

          • 7 committee ranking submitted - we need more input from all committee members.

          • Track2 "Real-time pattern recognition and fast tracking" (10 abstracts)

          • The other tracks (5~7 abstracts, multi-track counts considered)

      • Target

        • We aim on additional 22 talks acceptance  (20+10’).

        • Some of them can be converted to YSF (10+5’).

      • 1 query about late submission from Mike Hance@UCSC. He will discuss with ATLAS tracking conveners before abstract submission.

      • Shih-Chieh will assign each committee member to review one of the tracks. Each track will make recommendations of the abstract acceptance. Final decisions will be discussed on Nov 29.

    • 17:30 18:10
      Abstract review 40m

      Track1 Algorithms and theoretical analysis
      Alberto    Annovi, Martin    Heck, Benedikt    Hegner,

      Track2 Real-time pattern recognition and fast tracking
      Michel    De Cian, Markus    Elsing, Fabrizio    Palla, Maria    Spiropulu

      Track3 Machine Learning approaches
      Ariel    Schwartzman,  David    Rousseau, Cecile    Germain

      Track4 Performance Evaluation
      Maurice    Garcia-Sciveres, Andre    Schoening, Richard    Brenner, Andreas    Salzburger

      Track5 Advanced usage of tracks
      Marina    Artuso, Rudolf    Frühwirth, Frank    Gaede,

      Track6 Beyond he conventional Tracking
      Paolo    Calafiura, Eugenio    Paoloni, Are    Strandlie