# Open Symposium - European Strategy Preparatory Group

from to (Europe/Zurich)
at AGH AGH University of Science and Technology
Reymonta 7, Krakow, Poland
Go to day
• Sunday, 9 September 2012
• 18:00 - 20:00 Registration
• Monday, 10 September 2012
• 08:00 - 09:00 Registration
• 09:00 - 09:03 Opening  Convener: T. Nakada
• 09:03 - 09:30 Welcome Speeches  Convener: M. Skrzypek (Chair of the Local Organising Committee)
• 09:30 - 10:30 Introduction  Convener: T. Nakada Material:
• 09:30 Overview Talk 45'  Speaker: Antonio Masiero Material:
• 10:15 Discussion 15'
• 10:30 - 11:00 Coffee
• 11:00 - 12:35 Physics at High Energy Frontier and Flavour Physics
The session will first summarize the present experimental status of high-energy frontier physics and of flavour physics, as well as precision frontier physics on fundamental symmetries. The objective of this session is to further the understanding of the current status on these subjects before discussing how to proceed, with the aim of finding new physics phenomena beyond the Standard Model in the broad particle physics context.

Then, options for future projects at the highest energies and major projects in flavour physics are discussed.
Based on the experimental status presented in the morning session, the first talk will summarize the present state of the exploration of physics at the Terascale, point out the most important open questions, which theoretical models are proposing the most promising solutions and which are the main physics observables to be measured in the future.
In the second talk, the opportunities and ideas for future collider facilities and their physics case for the above topics will be presented with different emphasis, in particular
-	The LHC-HL physics programme
-	Electron positron collider at the EWSB scale
-	High-luminosity flavour programme
-	Physics of future high energy frontier with hadron and lepton colliders
-	Other opportunities (depending on the received input)
The discussion session will be structured into several parts (depending on the received input) covering (not necessarily exclusively)
-	Synthesis of the physics opportunities and their priorities
-	LHC high luminosity upgrade
-	Higgs factory
-	LC at higher energies
-	Flavour facilities
-	Multi-TeV projects

 Conveners: Y. Kuno, R. Forty (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 11:00 HEF Experiment Results 35'
30' + 5' discussion
 Speaker: Guenther Dissertori (ETH Zuerich) Material:
• 11:35 Flavour and Symmetries; Experiment Results 35'
30' + 5' discussion
 Speaker: Frederic Teubert (CERN) Material:
• 12:10 Charged Lepton Flavor and Symmetry Physics Implications 25'
20' + 5' discussion
 Speaker: Gino Isidori (Istituto Nazionale Fisica Nucleare) Material:
• 12:35 - 14:00 Lunch
• 14:00 - 16:30 Physics at High Energy Frontier and Flavour Physics
The session will first summarize the present experimental status of high-energy frontier physics and of flavour physics, as well as precision frontier physics on fundamental symmetries. The objective of this session is to further the understanding of the current status on these subjects before discussing how to proceed, with the aim of finding new physics phenomena beyond the Standard Model in the broad particle physics context.

Then, options for future projects at the highest energies and major projects in flavour physics are discussed.
Based on the experimental status presented in the morning session, the first talk will summarize the present state of the exploration of physics at the Terascale, point out the most important open questions, which theoretical models are proposing the most promising solutions and which are the main physics observables to be measured in the future.
In the second talk, the opportunities and ideas for future collider facilities and their physics case for the above topics will be presented with different emphasis, in particular
-	The LHC-HL physics programme
-	Electron positron collider at the EWSB scale
-	High-luminosity flavour programme
-	Physics of future high energy frontier with hadron and lepton colliders
-	Other opportunities (depending on the received input)
The discussion session will be structured into several parts (depending on the received input) covering (not necessarily exclusively)
-	Synthesis of the physics opportunities and their priorities
-	LHC high luminosity upgrade
-	Higgs factory
-	LC at higher energies
-	Flavour facilities
-	Multi-TeV projects

 Conveners: K. Desch, M. Diemoz, A. Lister (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 14:00 Implications on Possible New Physics from Direct and Indirect Measurements 35'  Speaker: Christophe Grojean (CERN) Material:
• 14:35 Next Step Facilities 40'  Speaker: Terry Wyatt (University of Manchester) Material:
• 15:15 Discussion 1h15'
• 16:30 - 17:00 Coffee
• 17:00 - 18:30 Strong Interaction Physics
In the session on strong interactions, an update will be given on the status and opportunities in this field.

In the first talk of this session an overview will be presented of the field of 'Strong Interactions and QCD at the High Energy Frontier'. Accurate QCD predictions are crucial for experiments at the LHC, in high energy cosmic ray studies, neutrino experiments and for future colliders. However, there are still many issues which require deeper theoretical understanding or more precise experimental input. Therefore, QCD studies remain an important part of the physics programs at existing and future facilities. The first talk will discuss open questions and present possible future options for QCD studies at fixed target and collider facilities (e.g. LHeC), focusing on measurements which require the use of large infrastructures.

The second talk in this session will be devoted to Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions. At the energy frontier of the LHC, the abundant production of hard probes (heavy quarks and jets) will be used by the major experiments ALICE, ATLAS, and CMS to investigate fundamental questions such as the degree of deconfinement in and the transport coefficients of this new state of matter. The experiments at the LHC will need significant upgrades in Pb-Pb luminosity to fully explore the physics potential of nuclear collisions at the high energy frontier.
At lower energies, experiments will focus on matter at extreme baryon density and the search for a possible critical endpoint. Third generation experiments in the regime of physics at high baryon density with very challenging luminosities are currently being discussed at GSI/FAIR, Dubna/NICA, and the CERN SPS facility to address questions related to the QCD phase diagram in this regime.
 Conveners: P. Braun-Munzinger, K. Kutak (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 17:00 Strong Interactions and QCD at the High Energy Frontier 30'  Speaker: Paul Newman (University of Birmingham) Material:
• 17:30 Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions 20'  Speaker: Harald Appelshaeuser (Johann-Wolfgang-Goethe Univ.) Material:
• 17:50 Discussion 40'
• Tuesday, 11 September 2012
• 09:00 - 10:20 Astroparticle Physics, Gravitation and Cosmology
In Europe, ApPEC associated with the Eranet ASPERA, coordinates research in Astroparticle Physics. These bodies have published a roadmap which contains the list of topics under consideration.
From this roadmap, the topics directly related to particle physics will be discussed in the session on Astroparticle Physics:
•	Direct and indirect WIMP dark matter searches
•	Axion searches
•	Neutrino properties extracted from experiments searching for neutrino-less double beta decay and from cosmological data.
•	Large underground detectors for the study of proton decay, low energy neutrino astrophysics and geo-neutrinos.
Long baseline neutrino oscillations and other topics related to neutrino physics will be discussed in the session on Physics of Neutrinos.
The talk Astroparticle Physics: status and open questions (C. Spiering) will give an overview of the situation in Europe. A short summary of the ApPEC roadmap will be given, with emphasis on the above topics, and including an overview of the input received from the community.
The second talk (S. Katsanevas) will summarize the situation in the Americas and Asia and will discuss the organizational issues for interregional coordination such as the Astroparticle Physics International Forum (APIF) of the OECD Global Science Forum.
The ApPEC roadmap can be found at http://www.aspera-eu.org/.

 Conveners: C. De Clercq, Pierre Brun (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 09:00 European Astroparticle Physics: Status and Vision 25'  Speaker: Christian Spiering (DESY) Material:
• 09:25 Summary of Activities in Regions Beyond Europe 25'  Speaker: Stavros Katsanevas (CNRS/IN2P3) Material:
• 09:50 Discussion 30'
• 10:20 - 10:50 Coffee
• 10:50 - 13:00 Physics of Neutrinos
The last CERN Strategy Process stated that it was essential to determine the value of theta13 to clarify the future experimental programme in neutrino physics.  Experiments have continued to make rapid progress, and that clarity has now been achieved, with an experimentally-determined value of theta13 almost as large as the previous limit and now known to roughly the same absolute accuracy as the other angles.  This opens the prospect to determine the mass hierarchy and search for CP violation with new "conventional" long-baseline experiments. After theoretical introduction on the importance of further measurements of the neutrino properties, in particular the oscillation parameters, the session will focus on a discussion of the proposed experiments and where the European effort should go. We will also discuss the longer-term strategy towards even more capable programmes and what R&D and other efforts are needed in the near term.  We need input on what support experiments (neutrino cross-sections, hadron production measurements, etc.) we should be preparing.  There is also the question of short-baseline indications of sterile neutrinos, where the experimental situation has become more complex since the last strategy.  We will discuss proposed experiments to address these questions and, once again, where European effort should be focused. We will also discuss the important topic of absolute neutrino mass, which is coupled to the discussions in the astroparticle physics section.
 Conveners: D. Wark, E. Fernandez Martinez (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 10:50 Phenomenology of Neutrino Oscillations and Current Situation 15'  Speaker: Pilar Hernandez (University of Valencia) Material:
• 11:05 Neutrino Mass Measurements 10'  Speaker: Hamish Robertson (University of Washington) Material:
• 11:15 Next Generation Accelerator Neutrino Projects - Long and Short Baseline 25'  Speaker: Marco Zito (IRFU-Centre d'Etudes de Saclay) Material:
• 11:40 Longer-term Accelerator and Future Reactor Neutrino Projects 20'  Speaker: Caren Hagner (Hamburg University) Material:
• 12:00 Discussion 1h0'
• 13:00 - 14:30 Lunch
• 14:30 - 16:30 Accelerator Science and Technology
The aim of this session is to carry out an overview of the technical status of the main accelerator projects and related R&D needed in order to match the physics objectives in particle physics. The on-going activities, including main R&D achievements, as well as remaining critical issues will be discussed. In particular, the issue of the projects readiness for construction will be addressed and possible technically-driven schedules (i.e. when could the project be launched and how long would the construction last) will be discussed on purely technical grounds, even though the estimated cost of the projects will be presented whenever possible.
For the very long term, exploratory accelerator R&D that might extend the current frontiers of reachable energy and intensity will also be discussed.
 Conveners: R. Aleksan, F. Zimmermann (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 14:30 High Energy 40'  Speaker: Caterina Biscari (Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN)) Material:
• 15:10 High Intensity 40'  Speaker: Mats Lindroos (ESS, on leave from CERN) Material: Slides
• 15:50 Discussion 40'
• 16:30 - 17:00 Coffee
• 17:00 - 18:30 Instrumentation, Computing and General Infrastructure
The science in future relies on the vitality and success of research and development of today. R&D in instrumentation has always been an important component of particle physics and a required driver for the discovery experiments of the future. In addition, particle physics has also stretched the boundaries of data intensive science to a global scale.  The LHC experiments together with the worldwide GRID collaboration (WLCG) have demonstrated the power of an integrated computing infrastructure for data process and analysis.
We will examine the state of detector R&D in particle physics and the developments and challenges that face the field in computing.  We will also examine the infrastructures for our science and the challenges of sustaining an experienced technical workforce and the large facilities required for detector construction.

 Conveners: P. McBride, E. Garutti (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 17:00 Detector R&D for Discovery Science 30'
20' + 10' discussion
 Speaker: Ariella Cattai (CERN) Material:
• 17:30 Construction of Large Scale Projects - Technical Capabilities and Infrastructure 30'
20' + 10' discussion

 Speaker: Jim Virdee (Imperial College Sci., Tech. & Med.) Material:
• 18:00 Computing and Data Management for Particle Physics in 2020 30'
20' + 10' discussion

 Speaker: Tommaso Boccali (Sezione di Pisa) Material:
• Wednesday, 12 September 2012
• 09:00 - 10:30 Particle Physics Theory
The first talk will provide an overview of the various branches of particle physics theory, with some historical perspective. It will consider the role of particle theory within the field of particle physics and how it is currently organized, with comments for the future.
The second talk will review the spectrum of current problems in particle physics addressed with the methods of lattice quantum field theory; it will also comment on organizational aspects and on the role of Europe on the global scene in this field.
Both talks will take into account, if relevant, possible input submitted by the community.
The overall discussion at the end of the session may cover not only the subjects of the two talks but also: CERN synergies with regional/national/local theory groups, in Europe and in the rest of the world; relations with EU programmes; relations with experiment (“embedded” theorists, collaboration between experiment and theory to optimize analysis and presentation of experimental data, access by theorists to experimental data, etc.); development of software packages.
 Conveners: K. Huitu, P. Slavich (Scientific Secretary) Material:
• 09:00 The Role of Theory for Particle Physics 40'  Speaker: Luis Alvarez-Gaume (CERN) Material:
• 09:40 Quantum Field Theory on the Lattice 20'  Speaker: Christine Davies (University of Glasgow) Material:
• 10:00 Discussion 30'
• 10:30 - 11:00 Coffee
• 11:00 - 13:00 Status of Other Regions and Closing Discussion  Convener: T. Nakada Material:
• 11:00 Americas 30'  Speaker: Andrew J Lankford (University of California, Irvine) Material:
• 11:30 Discussion 10'
• 11:40 Asia Pacific 30'  Speaker: Prof. Masanori Yamauchi (KEK) Material:
• 12:10 Discussion 10'
• 12:20 Closing Discussion 40'  Material:
• 13:00 - 14:30 Lunch