ASP Covid-19 Exercise

→ UTC
Ketevi Adikle Assamagan (Brookhaven National Laboratory (US))
    • 12:00 → 12:10
      Comments from Referees 10m

      Editor and Reviewer comments:

      Reviewer #1: The paper is very well organized. The authors discuss a hot topic which is the COVI-19 pandemic. The work can be thought of as deep data analysis and modeling using state-of-the-art models. The analysis are perfects; we can blame them for not having taken into consideration all the countries of Africa.

      Indeed, the paper analyzed 12 months of COVID-19 data of Cameroon, Ghana, Kenya, Madagascar, Mozambique, Rwanda, South Africa, Togo and Zambia. For each country, the authors they estimated the time-dependent basic reproduction number, R0. At the onset of the pandemic, R0 was above one in all the cases studied. Over time, the basic reproduction numbers followed the fluctuation patters reflected in the data. From the results the variations were correlated with the control actions imposed and the emergence of new cases. About one year since the first cases were noticed in the countries studied, all the R0 were about or below one, suggesting that the pandemic had slowed in these countries. Though, since the virus may mutate and new waves are likely to occur, the word suggests to uphold the control measures until enough vaccines have been administered to reach herd immunity. Our studies also estimated the fractions of the population that were infected and not diagnosed but
      recovered without symptoms; in general, they find that these fractions are between 1 -10% of the recovered cases.

      The problem with this study is the conclusion that vaccination will allow the epidemic to disappear. But the study did not mention secondary effects of vaccination in some cases. In addition, any vaccine must be administered or kept, especially the mutated virus.

      For the acceptance of this work it is necessary that the authors explain these points more
      1. Will the vaccine be able to fight against the virus and with what level of effectiveness?
      2. According to this study which vaccine should be taken
      3. How to deal with mutated variants of the virus.
      4. If you are well after being infected with the virus why do the vaccination.

      Reviewer #2: The proposed paper aims at analyzing the COVID-19 pandemic evolution in African countries according to a data model
      including active, recovered and death cases.
      The study is very interesting since it analyzes many African countries with result comparison and discussion
      of the given graphs.
      To improve this work, Authors should consider the following comments,
      - How to include the impact of the vaccine process on the basic reproduction numbers and
      reinforce the used model as expressed in Eq (1).
      - Each country is analyzed independently. I propose to discuss the model and analyze the evolution if we take all the countries as one data set.

    • 12:10 → 12:30
      Analysis of Mozambique with current data 20m
      Speaker: Toivo Mabote (Eduardo Mondlane University, Mozambique)