Studies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from detectors at the LHC
by
A wide range of gas mixtures is used to operate gaseous detectors at the CERN LHC experiments. Some of these gases, namely C2H2F4, CF4, SF6, C4F10, are classified as Greenhouse Gases (GHG) with a high Global Warming Potential. They are therefore subjected to a phase-down policy affecting their price and market availability. These gases are responsible for 70% of CERN's direct greenhouse gas emissions. The Organisation’s objective is to reduce such emissions by 28% by the end of 2024 with respect to 2018. The present work shows the development of two main research strategies delineated by the EP-DT gas group to reduce GHG emissions. Wherever suitable, large detector volumes are operated with recirculating gas systems.
The first part of the studies done focused on optimizing existing gas system technologies to improve operating performances and further reduce gas consumption. In particular, dedicated monitoring infrastructures were designed to properly tune the active control parts of the different gas modules. Furthermore, specific data analysis pipelines were developed to evaluate the gas system performance and to monitor the gas consumption.
A second part of the work consisted in studying the performance of RPC detectors operated with alternative gases. RPCs in the ATLAS and CMS experiments are operated with a three-component gas mixture mainly based on C2H2F4 (GWP =1430), around 5% of i-C4H10, and a minor fraction of 0.3% of SF6 (GWP = 22800). Due to the presence of leaks at the detector level, C2H2F4 dominates the overall CERN GHG emissions. Alternatives to C2H2F4 were identified in R-1234ze, a molecule in the family of HydroFluoroOlefins with a GWP of 7, while SF6 alternatives were found in the Novec family (Novec 4710 and Novec 5110), C4F8O, CF3I, and R-1224yd.
RPC performance with gas mixtures based on alternative gases was firstly evaluated in laboratory conditions by studying the detector efficiency, currents, streamer probability, prompt charge, cluster size, and time resolution. Few selected gas mixtures were then tested at the Gamma Irradiation Facility, which provides muon beam and gamma background radiation, allowing to emulate the High Luminosity LHC background conditions. Few gas mixtures showed similar rate capability with respect to the standard gas mixture. Long-term performance studies were started, and preliminary studies on impurity productions for HFO-based gas mixtures are presented, showing the R-1234ze molecule produces an order of magnitude more F- ions than the C2H2F4 one.
Roberto Guida and Burkhard Schmidt (EP-DT)