Minutes from Discussion of FCC Dataset Management System
Present: Andre, Birgit, Brieuc, Giovanni, Jan, Juraj, Louis
- Rucio + DIRAC are still not enough to cover all needs
- In terms of metadata
- ATLAS has additional AMI service to provide detailed metadata
- No full metadata catalog in Rucio
- Plugin can add this functionality
- In case of Rucio we would need to come up with a dataset naming convention
- Rucio provided as a CERN IT service for small experiments
- No big hiccups encountered during the Pilot period
- Not all actually started using it
- Rucio containers can be nested
- In newer versions there can "one line address"
- Users are required to have x509 or token
- This rises a bar for the common analyzer to join
- Work under way to integrate with CERN Keykloak (Auth service)
- Dataset relations are present in Rucio only as the file name/metadata
- Dirac file catalog has it build in
- We need provenance graphs when the data sample production will get more complex (FCC-hh)
- FTS handles the Rucio data transfers
- Dirac has plugin for it as well
- We agreed to set up CNAF SE as Rucio SE and investigate the usage and needs
- Validation capabilities boil down to metadata fields
- Monitoring tools need to be set up separately and then brought to Rucio
- Dirac DMS and Rucio are very similar capabilities wise
- DIRAC can have diverse set of plugin
- DIRAC can also be described as declarative
- User production to be moved fully to DIRAC
- No need for personal EventProducer
- We need to have user production process as close to the real production as possible
- Dirac user job can output to a common scratch disk and Rucio will pick the samples there (and turn them into official production)
- Physics dataset validation is handled only by the MC production manager (Louis)
- We need more people to join the effort
- Can be handled in the FCC Physics website by metadata flag
- The physics validation started to be developed at the PF workshop last week, not operational yet
There are minutes attached to this event.
Show them.