Tau Reconstruction Meeting

→ Europe/Zurich
Laurits Tani (National Institute of Chemical Physics and Biophysics (EE)), Michel Hernandez Villanueva (Brookhaven National Laboratory (US))
Zoom Meeting ID
63547815524
Host
Laurits Tani
Useful links
Join via phone
Zoom URL

FCC Tau Reconstruction - November 20, 2026

Present: Laurits Tani, Michel Hernandez Villanueva, Mohadeseh Dadashzadeh, Olmo Arquero, Karl Ehataht, Norman Seeba

CMS Hadron-Plus-Strips (HPS) algorithm and tuning for FCC (Laurits)

  • Overview of the CMS HPS tau reconstruction algorithm and its evolution from Run 1 to Run 2+
    • Charged hadrons and electrons form prongs; photons and electrons are clustered into 𝜂-𝜙 “strips” to reconstruct 𝜋0 decays (wide in 𝜙 due to bending in the strong magnetic field)
    • Constructs decay mode hypotheses (1-prong, 1-prong+1𝜋0, 1-prong+2𝜋0, 3-prong, 3-prong+1𝜋0) targeting intermediate resonances (𝜌, 𝑎1)
    • Applies kinematic, mass-window, and signal-cone cuts; surviving candidates are ranked by charge multiplicity (3-prong over 1-prong), 𝑝𝑇, number of strips, and isolation
    • HPS handles candidate reconstruction (decay mode and visible 4-momentum), whereas tau identification was later decoupled and delegated to ML classifiers (DeepTau)
  • Key design updates across CMS versions
    • Transitioned from fixed to 𝑝𝑇-dependent dynamic strip sizes to account for photon conversions and collimation at high 𝑝𝑇 in busy 𝑝𝑝 environments
    • Tight cuts initially reduced fake rates at the cost of ~50% efficiency; cuts were later loosened once DeepTau was introduced on top
  • Re-implementation and hyperparameter optimization for FCC-ee
    • Re-implemented CMSSW HPS in Python using Numba for fast execution
    • Evaluated on 270,000 jets from 𝑍→𝜏𝜏 full simulation samples with the CLD detector geometry (half for optimization, half for evaluation)
    • Tuned 50 of the 84 total HPS parameters (23 decay mode cuts, 18 strip building, 6 signal cone, 3 global) using Optuna (Tree-structured Parzen Estimator) across 5,000 trials and 8 random seeds
    • Two concurrent optimization objectives: decay mode classification accuracy (across 5 modes) and visible momentum resolution
  • Optimization results and performance
    • Significant improvement in decay mode accuracy and a twofold improvement in momentum resolution compared to default CMSSW parameters, approaching the ideal MC-truth matching limit
    • Notably recovered classification performance for the 1-prong+2𝜋0 decay mode (previously misclassified due to strip merging in default settings)
    • fANOVA parameter importance analysis identified minimum strip 𝑝𝑇 among the most impactful parameters

Questions/comments

  • How does the retuned HPS algorithm perform on background rejection (e.g., 𝑍→𝑞𝑞¯), given that only 𝑍→𝜏𝜏 samples were used in the tuning?
    • Not yet tested, as looser cuts are viable at FCC-ee where ML taggers handle background separation well, though Laurits will run the retuned HPS on a 𝑍→𝑞𝑞¯ sample to check candidate survival rates
  • Comparison with existing FCC heuristic approaches (Sofia and Olmo’s cone-based algorithms)
    • Those approaches resemble early CMS cone-based tau reconstruction; in an informal test, Olmo’s algorithm outperformed retuned HPS in efficiency due to HPS’s tighter cuts, though a fair comparison requires checking background rates
  • Is there any constraint placed on the median of 𝑝reco/𝑝vis (or 𝑝gen) to stay close to 1 and avoid momentum scale biases?
    • No explicit constraint was enforced on the median during optimization
  • Follow-up / Next steps
    • Michel to review CMS detector features in relation to the HPS design choices to understand which aspects translate to FCC detector concepts
    • Laurits to evaluate 𝑍→𝑞𝑞¯ background survival rates with the tuned parameters

AOB

  • Open call for volunteers to present overviews of other existing reconstruction algorithms in future meetings
There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.
    • 12:00 → 12:10
      Introduction 10m
      Speakers: Laurits Tani (National Institute of Chemical Physics and Biophysics (EE)), Michel Hernandez Villanueva (Brookhaven National Laboratory (US))
    • 12:10 → 12:30
      Tau reconstruction at CMS 20m
      Speaker: Laurits Tani (National Institute of Chemical Physics and Biophysics (EE))
    • 12:30 → 13:00
      Round table 30m