Restarting Neutrino+Gamma Subgroup Meetings

→ Europe/Zurich
Judit Pérez-Romero (IFIC UV/CSIC), Saptashwa Bhattacharyya (Waseda University)

Key Outcomes
The group reviewed outputs from the EuCAIF Heidelberg workshop and the Lorentz Center meeting to shape a roadmap for the Gamma-Ray/Neutrino working group. Two near-term meeting themes were agreed upon: (1) event reconstruction for gamma-rays and neutrinos and tranferable learning, and (2) multi-messenger source analysis. Coordination with the Multi-Messenger and Cutting-Edge Methods subgroups was flagged as essential to avoid duplication, particularly around foundation model development.
Decisions Made
    •    Next two meetings structured around: (1) event reconstruction (IceCube paper + Thomas Vuillaume's EuCAIF talk) and (2) source analysis (Youyou Li's SBI work + gamma-ray worsk with Fermi-LAT and CTAO ) 
    •    Invite Gamma-ray working team from the Lorentz Center Workshop 
    •    Gamma-ray and neutrino tracks could run in parallel rather than sequentially, given complementary scope 
    •    Coordinate with Cutting-Edge Methods group, which plans emulators for neutrino physics (e.g., replacing CORSIKA with diffusion models) 
Key Technical Discussion
    •    EuCAIF breakdown: ~95% of talks were LHC-focused (jet tagging, event reconstruction); cosmology ~4%; astrophysics ~1%
    •    Neutrino challenges: low count statistics (e.g., NGC 1068 significance ~4σ, well below 5σ threshold), making source localization difficult 
    •    Youyou Li's SBI approach: applied CNN + SBI to a toy IceCube-like model with diffuse + unresolved source components; injected values recovered with reasonable posterior intervals
    •    Three differentiated pipeline steps identified: (1) event reconstruction, (2) source identification and characterization, (3) dedicated source emulator
    •    Foundation model scope: likely requires at least three separate models for the three pipeline stages, not one unified model 
Cross-Group Alignment
    •    Multi-Messenger group (Nachiketa + Peter + Xiaofei): building simulated kilonova dataset combining gravitational wave and EM signatures for source classification — bottom-up approach 11
    •    Gravitational waves subgroup: ~10 active members, bi-weekly meetings, pipeline and foundation model strategy already defined 
    •    Shared interest in latent space representation methods across both working groups 
    •    Judit and Suvo to will join multi-messenger group meeting 
Pending Confirmation
    •    Overlap with Cutting-Edge Methods group on neutrino emulators needs explicit coordination to avoid redundancy 
Open Questions
    •    Whether a foundation model trained across multiple experiments (gamma-ray + neutrino) is feasible given differing data formats and statistics 
    •    How to combine gamma-ray and neutrino data to improve source localization (e.g., reducing search radius from ~5° to ~1°) 
    •    Leptonic vs. hadronic production discrimination requires dedicated source physics simulation — manpower and scope not yet defined 
Action Items
    •    Judit + Shuvo: Contact gamma-ray's Lorentz Workshop Team & Thomas Vuillaume; set up a Doodle to schedule their participation.
    •    All: Consider joining the next cross-cutting methods group meeting 
    •    Nachiketa: Circulate update to broader mailing list once kilonova pilot dataset and initial tasks are finalized 

There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.
    • 15:00 → 15:10
      Re-starting of the meetings & introduction of new members 10m
      Speakers: Judit Pérez-Romero (IFIC UV/CSIC), Saptashwa Bhattacharyya (Waseda University)
    • 15:10 → 15:35
      Discussion on EuCAIFCon 2026 ideas/presentations/discussion topics 25m

      https://indico.physi.uni-heidelberg.de/event/1277/

    • 15:35 → 15:55
      Discussion about Next Steps for the WG 20m
    • 15:55 → 16:05
      AOB 10m