Participants: Jingbo, Todd, Cigdem, Francois, Karl, Jan, Tony, KK
We discussed the draft of the cumulative document and these are the comments Cigdem received:
- Tony mentioned that the dose and fluence description of the SLHC environment should only be mentioned at one place in the document: section 2.
- Karl would like to have figure of the radiation dose in the detector.
- Cigdem will contact Ian Dowsan and ask him for a plot.
- The title of the document will be changed to "CMS/ATLAS Optical Readout System Irradiation Protocols".
- We agreed that the phrase "radiation hardness" will be replaced by "radiation tolerance" throughout the document.
- We will include a table with the components addressed in this document with what tests are needed to be done with them. This table will be included into the introduction of the document.
- The Appendix A will contain a list of radiation sources with internal and external contact persons.
- Francois comment that we need to make sure that the proposals A,B and C have a common appearance.
- He will send us the title page of proposal A as a template.
- We will use the titles of the proposals A,B and C for now to cross reference them.
- Instead of forms for irradiation tests and sample validations we will have checklist.
- Karl will write a checklist for the irradiation tests.
- In general the document's main text body should not go into too much details, these should be shifted to the appendix section of the document, which can grow with time.
- We will have section with the history of the changes of the document.
- The section about sample sizes will be edited by Karl and Tony and will incorparate the concerns Tony raised about the Poisson statistics. And Karl suggested that it should also include a history of the sample sizes used for the LHC radiation tests.
- We agreed that what is currently in section 1 (Introduction) should be moved to section 2. Section 1 should contain the scope of the document and the components addressed in it in general. It should mention a future to be written document about "quality assurance and reliability teststings".
- Section 3 will be erased.
- Section 4.7 and 4.8 will be erased.
- Section's 2 title will be changed to "Radiation Environment at the SLHC".
- Section's 4.6 title will be changed to "Effects of Irradiation on Ageing and Long Term Reliabiltiy".
- Section 4.2 (Failure Criteria) should have a brief discussion about that these tests are accelerated tests and extrapolation measurements to the real environment will depend on the tests results. Annealing data will be necessary in order to be able to extrapolate results.
- We agreed to have our next meeting on the 17.08.07 at 15:00 CERN time.
- Cigdem will distribute a new version of this document on 10.08.07.
- Karl, Tony and Jingbo will send the material they agreed to provide to Cigdem latest by 04.08.07.
There are minutes attached to this event.
Show them.