EDM4HEP Discussion #4

Europe/Zurich
1/1-025 (CERN)

1/1-025

CERN

20
Show room on map
Videoconference Rooms
EDM4HEP
Name
EDM4HEP
Description
Vidyo connection for EDM4HEP discussions
Extension
10832559
Owner
Andre Sailer
Auto-join URL
Useful links
Phone numbers

EDM4HEP Live Notes

Present: Valentin, Graeme, Andre, Geri, David, Xiaomei, Xingtao, someone else from IHEP

Introduction and General Points

Agree to go for EDM4hep (if you really care argue on github)

Valentin will contact Acts people.

EDM4HEP Progress and Discussion

ROOT RDataFrame integrations

An important aspect of EDM4HEP is usability, which includes that the implementation plays nicely with standard workflows, p.ex. TTree->Draw(.. .
RDataFrame seems to have a lot of momentum and support so should be thought of as well.
I (Valentin) was asked to present some work I previously did on the usage of RDataFrame in FCC Analyses at the next ROOT Parallel Programming meeting.
Since these analyses use the FCC-edm/podio this is a very related topic, and it will be good opportunity to give the root devs a chance to voice their thoughts.

To quickly summarize what I did: None of the FCC Analyses actually need to use any relations, so I construct a RDataFrame from the plain root file (which is filled with std::vector<EDMTYPEData> and write some lambdas to do the needed operations (mainly filtering, tagging, calculating resonances etc …)). Here is an example of what that looks like: https://github.com/vvolkl/FCChhAnalyses/blob/3f328dddb8b0f2dba5a5dcde34a8d3eb88d47b3b/FCChhAnalyses/FCChh/tth_4l/dataframe/fcc_ana_tth_4l.cxx

(There was some more work involved to be able to use the configuration files from another analysis library, heppy with RDataFrame, but that’s not too relevant for EDM4HEP)

Are these lambdas are specific to the EDM? Could perhaps be supported directly in PODIO? Frank thinks so.

Example is calculating the p_t from an MC particle (doing this on a vector of particles, in particular).

Valentin will feedback after the ROOT meeting.

Composition of hit and position

https://github.com/HSF/EDM4HEP/blob/master/edm4hep.yaml#L133

https://github.com/HEP-FCC/fcc-edm/blob/master/edm.yaml#L174

Code Review!

Have a look at the examples that Frank put in - ACTION on everyone.

There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.