FCC-ee tuning WG meeting
R. Tomas announces that J. Keintzel will be the scientific secretary and co-chair of the FCC tuning meetings. Furthermore, IPAC paper drafts are presently being prepared and need to be finished soon.
E. Ahmadi presents updates of multipole errors in the FCC-ee at Z and ttbar-energy using ELEGANT. Compared to the last presentation, b4 errors in QY* and QC* are investigated one by one and b6-errors are studied. Including b4 errors of either 1e-5 or 1e.6 in QY* elements yields a DA close to the ideal case. Including b4 errors of either 1e-5 or 1e-6 in QC* elements reveal that QC1 and QC2 (tolerance 1e-6) are more sensitive than QC3-7 (tolerance 1e-5). Especially in vertical DA a smaller DA is observed with b4 errors in QC elements. With 1e-4 b6-errors present in QA and QB elements strongly reduces the DA at the Z-mode. The situation is enhanced if b6 is included in QC and QY (tolerance 1e-6) elements. Methods including octupoles could be explored to increase DA. The ttbar-lattice is, in general, less sensitive to errors compared to the Z-lattice. An updated tolerance table is presented and given below. It is not yet concluded on b6 in IR quadrupoles since used tolerances as low as 1e-6 still disturb the DA and thus the limit is below that value. R. Tomas reminds that in the last meeting magnet experts commented that 1e-6 seems too optimistic and instead corrector magnets should be placed strategically. K. Oide confirms that locations for multipole correctors could be found, however, it should be aimed improving field quality. R. Tomas comments that future studies could be performed including synchrotron radiation. Furthermore, K. Oide proposes to explore sorting techniques since here presented errors are systematically.
Following a question by R. Tomas, E. Ahmadi comments that the tolerances are defined as the maximum values without noticeable reduction in DA. R. Tomas comments that this definition might be a bit too strict and a more operational limit could be envisaged.

S. Liuzzo presents an extensive comparison between K. Oide's (V22) and P. Raimondi's (HFD51) lattices using accelerator toolbox. R. Tomas notes that in the FCC optics meeting on 16/03/2023 M. Hofer has presented a comparison of the DA. R. Tomas comments that e.g. on Tune vs Y the shapes are interesting. P. Raimondi comments that the suspected reason is that the limit of DA or MA is reached in these studies, furthermore, the initial working point is set to .33 and .33 in the HFD-lattice and is thus not optimal. In the presented DA comparison including RF does not reduce DA in V22, but it does with HFD-lattice. P. Raimondi comments that the origin of the change in DA with/without RF is the path lengthening. Nevertheless, the latter provides a larger DA at both energy regimes. D. Shatilov comments that DA strongly depends on the tunes and thus here presented results do not correctly reflect the lattice properties. P. Raimondi comments that with the correct tunes DA is expected to be improved, which needs to be confirmed. P. Raimondi comments that slight differences between SAD, MAD and pyAT have been observed, and the latter seems to provide a slightly more pessimistic result. The local momentum acceptance presented by S. Liuzzo is found below 0.5 % in the arcs. P. Raimondi comments that this result is a convolution of the curly-H function, MA and transverse acceptance, specially important for Touschek-like effects. Furthermore, this makes the arcs more radiation sensitive (requiring longer quadrupoles) and HFD tolerates slightly shorter arc MQs. Including random alignment errors in 600/880 arc sextupoles for the lattices V22/HFD51 and the impact on the optics is studied (.2, .33 working point for HFD) without corrections. The same amount of generated beta-beating/dispersion/emittance is achieved with about 3-4times larger misalignment errors in HFD-lattice at the Z-lattice. At the ttbar-lattice the advantages of HFD are smaller and about 50%. Including random alignment errors in arc quadrupoles at Z/ttbar-mode and the impact on the optics is studied (.2, .33 working point for HFD) without corrections. At the Z-lattice V22 is about a factor 2 less sensitive to these errors concerning optics beating, while at ttbar-lattice HFD performs slightly better. P. Raimondi comments that the average orbit generated should be added. Furthermore, P. Raimondi notes that ttbar-lattices seem more sensitive to errors. R. Tomas comments that the situation will improve once the orbit is corrected. In general the HFD is found less sensitive to misalignment errors in the arc quadrupoles and sextupoles. A summary table is given below.
Complementary, progress on the rms closed-orbit, tunes, chromaticity and optics correction using the analytical approach is shown using the V22 lattice without solenoid or radiation. R. Tomas comments that the horizontal emittance with errors and corrections is slightly better than the design value. P. Raimondi comments that this could be from a change in partition number. Furthermore, he comments that due to an orbit in the sextupoles will always result in a positive kick in the order of µrad. D. Shatilov notes that although emittance is good, DA and MA are drastically reduced. P. Raimondi comments that presented DA is probably still acceptable and errors typically reduce DA to about 70% of the error-free value. R. Tomas asks about parameters at the IP (coupling, beta-beating, orbit, tune advance between IPs, etc.) which could be aimed to be provided in future studies. D. Shatilov comments that L. van Riesen-Haupt presented knobs for IP tuning, which, while improving the optics errors, DA does not improve. Thus, knobs should be carefully evaluated and optimized. P. Raimondi comments that maximum acceptable tolerances on IP parameters could be studied by beam-beam simulations. R. Tomas comments that e.g. beta-beating at the IP is found to be typically worse compared to the rest of the lattice.
D. Shatilov comments that even the ideal lattice is already challenging due to symmetry breaking caused by only one RF-section. With 4 IP this leads to a resonance crossing, which is not the case for 2 IPs. Reducing crab-sextupoles to 80% has already shown to be promising. As a next step it is aimed performing simulations on a lattice with errors.
