LHCHiggsXSect: MSSM Higgs WG meeting

→ Europe/Zurich
40-5-A08 (CERN)

40-5-A08

CERN


Present:
M. Flechl, S. Heinemeyer, R. Harlander, M. Kraemer, S. Laurila,
S. Lehti, H. Rzehak, P. Slavich, M. Vazquez Acosta

MSSM Neutral Higgs
-----------------------------
8 TeV Cross Section grids in the mhmax, no-mixing scenario
were completed and released to the experiments to be used
for ICHEP results.

* Pending items and next steps

1) The GammaGamma/WW BR in the mhmax scenario were
provided by Sven/Michael Spira/Daniela Rebuzzi following
the BR group recommendation. The no-mixing scenario will
be provided today too. Work is on-going to include this in
the cross section grids.

2) A detailed comparison of the ggH calculations of R. Harlander
and P. Slavich is on-going. The SM part and the scalar top part
is under control. The scalar bottom part is being worked on.
The largest disagreement comes in the implementation of
the Delta_b corrections in the couplings.
Discussion on the parameter choices to included the susy loop
corrections are ongoing. Need to come up with a prescription
which has some physics motivation behind it.
Robert and Pietro estimate they need an order of two weeks
to settle down on technical issues. A smaller meeting has
already been arranged to progress in this front.

3) Heidi presented a detailed comparison of FeynHiggs (FH)
2.7.4 and 2.8.6, which have both been tested when creating
the MSSM Higgs cross section grids.

Slides are uploaded to the agenda:
http://indico.cern.ch/conferenceDisplay.py?confId=195953

The coupling ratios are consistent although there is a slight
shift of the two distributions.

For the bb coupling (Slide 7) one can see there was a bug in
2.7.4 in the low MA values for the heavy Higgs coupling and
in the high MA values for the light Higgs coupling. This is now
fixed in the newer version 2.8.6.

The results between the two versions do not lead to
substantial differences (although full decoupling is only
achieved in the new FeynHiggs version) and so the authors
do not insist to move the cross section grids to FH 2.8.6.
If time permits, maybe we should redo our 7 TeV scan
with this newer version.

Sven announced that a new version 2.9.0 was released today.
Feedback on the usage of this new version is welcome.


MSSM Charged Higgs
------------------------------

1) M. Kraemer presented plots on the 5FS heavy charged Higgs
calculations from him and his collaborators. No SUSY corrections
are included and the cross sections have been calculated for
a value of tanbeta=30.

Preliminary plots can be seen in the agenda:
https://indico.cern.ch/conferenceDisplay.py?confId=195953

for MSTW, CT10, NNPDF separately and including
the PDF envelope.

A strange feature is seen with NNPDF. When the alphas uncertainties
are also included the total uncertainty decreases.
This is being investigated together with the NNPDF authors.

For the factorization scale, the recommendation of a recent
paper of F. Maltoni was used, which depends on the Higgs mass.
Full details will be circulated to the list. Scale has been varied
by a factor 2, but a discussion on this is on-going.

The dominant uncertainty comes from the PDF variation and
the b-mass uncertainty. A cross-check that the b-mass is
consistently varied in the PDF and the calculation needs to
be done.

The production of 4FS cross section numbers are in progress.

M. Flechl volunteered to cross check the numbers and later
take over the code to produce a full tanbeta mH+ grid, as
this is quite a CPU intensive task, specially the 4FS calculation.
S. Lehti also volunteered to help with this.


Target: have cross section numbers for experiments
to produce results for the Charged Higgs Workshop,
Uppsala, 8-12 October.

2) S. Lehti et al are doing different studies with FeynHiggs.
    i) Study the dependence of the t-> bH+ and H+ decay
       widths on SUSY parameters
   ii) Study the dependence of the cross sections with
       SUSY parameters


AOB
-----------------
* Pietro reminded that the discussion on recommended
parameters of FeynHiggs was not closed. Sven et al
plan to meet and come up with an official recommendation.

* Sami said he is seeing strange relations between MW, MA
 and MH+ in FeynHiggs. He will discuss with Heidi offline and
 try to see what the issue is.

 

There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.
    • 15:00 → 15:20
      Neutral MSSM Higgs plans 20m
      Speaker: All
      Plots from Heidi Rzehak: FeynHiggs 274vs286
    • 15:20 → 15:40
      Charged Higgs status and plans 20m
      Speaker: All
      M. Kraemer: 5FS H+ XSect CT10
      M. Kraemer: 5FS H+ XSect MSTW
      M. Kraemer: 5FS H+ XSect NNPDF
      M. Kraemer: 5 FS H+ XSect, PDF envelope