LIU-SPS Coordination Meeting
Zoom
Present: Alexandre Lasheen, Andy Butterworth, Anthony Rey, Antonio Grande Mallavia, Arthur Spierer, Brennan Goddard, Carlo Zannini, Chiara Pasquino, Christine Vollinger, Christos Zamantzas, Danilo Quartullo, David Mcfarlane, David Nisbet, Elena Chapochnikova, Eric Montesinos, Kiki Veyrunes, Etienne Carlier, Fabio Follin, Francesco Maria Velotti, Francois-Xavier Nuiry, Frank Gerigk, Gerd Kotzian, Giovanni Rumolo, Giulia Papotti, Gregoire Hagmann, Hannes Bartosik, Heiko Damerau, Ivan Karpov, Ivan Romera Ramirez , James Ridewood, Johan Dalla-Costa, Johannes Bernhard, Julie Coupard, Kevin Shing Bruce Li, Leandro Intelisano, Loic De Oliveira, Luciana Kolbeck, Maciej Suminski, Marine Gourber-Pace, Michael Barnes, Nicolas Magnin, Paul Cruikshank, Philippe Baudrenghien, Reyes Alemany Fernandez, Simon Albright, Stephane Cettour Cave, Tom Levens, Verena Kain, Wolfgang Hofle, Yannick Le Borgne, Zisou Charilaos
Matters arising and actions
- ACTION - A. Butterworth: provide update on interlock interfaces along with available diagnostics (interlock tree - what triggered the dump?) - system delivery expected by March;
- ACTION - P. Baudrenghien: update simulation results with input parameters from operational scenarios, i.e., injected beam will be 2.6e11, 2.4e11 towards end of ramp; calculation for power with 10 kW outside beam segments; new algorithms for power optimization;
- ACTION - Kevin: Organize meeting to prepare stretched cycles for power reduction;
- ACTION - Kevin, Reyes, Giulia and Theo: look at parameter model of slip stacking to be implemented in LSA (e.g. duplicate RF voltage parameter);
Status of Low Impedance MKP-L and Spare (M. Barnes)
- A refined analysis of operational scenarios showed that the MKPL beam induced heating is expected to limit SPS operation and the performance ramp-up towards LIU beam parameters during MDs arleady earlier during Run 3 than originally expected. The planned MDs in 2022 are expected to bring the MKP-L already close (or beyond) the damage limit.
- The rate of heating and dissipated power was studied in simulations showing that the long-term heating rates are proportional to the average dissipated power. High rates of heating can result in mechanical damage (cracking of ferrite legs).
- The temperature probe in the kicker is located at the ground conductor, which is actually not a good indicator for the ferrite temperature. The safe temperature of the ground conductor in operation thus depends on the rate of heating.
- The permeability of the magnet changes as a function of temperature, in particular at the Curie temperature, which results in a change of delay of the magnet pulse. Measuring the delay thus could be a way of detecting if the magnet has reached the Curie temperature. However, there are 22 cells in the magnet and the first cells to see beam heat are predicted to heat at a higher rate.
- An upgrade of the MKP-L is under way, retrofitting serigraphy on alumina plates (coated with Cr2O3 for e-cloud reduction) which will be inserted into the MKP-L aperture. Field measurements on the risetime show hardly any difference with or without these plates installed on the prototype.
- Some arcing between HV busbar and 1st serigraphy finger was observed on the kicker flat top, at the transition from the HV busbar to the alumina plate. A further test will be done where the alumina plate will be moved away from the HV busbar. Nevertheless, there would still be an open question for e-cloud build-up at the gap between the alumina plates and the HV busbar. A potential solution requires reducing horizontal aperture by 7 mm, which seems acceptable (first checks by Francesco).
- It is proposed to keep the MKP voltage balancing implemented since 2016, to reduce voltage breakdowns at the first MKP-L module since the reason for the breakdowns is not clear.
- The original plan was to have the upgraded MKP-L ready by November, but it will not be ready due to issues mentioned before. Present focus is to have the spare MKP-L equipped to be ready for installation. The next steps are to implement changes to the prototype and find a solution for the e-cloud issue.
- Elena asked if it is clear that e-cloud is an issue. Mike explained that this is a conclusion based on experimental observations in LHC dilution kickers. The e-cloud team could perform studies in case of need.
- As additional information, two issues were observed with the previously installed MKP-L: e-cloud and outgassing due to the fact that these magnets could not be baked out (they were not designed for that). Some studies performed on an MKE spare showed that low temperature bake-out was effective for reducing outgassing. This could be tested on the MKP-L, as also the outgassing due to heating could be the main issue and not e-cloud, but would require tooling to transport the magnet under vacuum into the tunnel. E-cloud conditioning without beam before installation seems technically more difficult.
Results from MKP-L impedance measurement (C. Zannini)
- Power loss and thus beam induced heating is directly related to the real part of the longitudinal impedance and the overlap with the beam spectrum. The longitudinal segmentation of the MKP-L results in an increase of the longitudinal impedance.
- The serigraphy installed in the MKEs significantly reduced the beam induced heating of these kickers, so that the remaining issue in the SPS is now the MKP-L. The serigraphy concept developed for the MKEs was adapted to the MKP-L, applying 4, 5 or 6 stripes along the longitudinal magnet axis.
- The effect of the serigraphy thickness was studied in simulation, as during the fabrication process a small non-conformity of the thickness was reported. However, the shielding efficiency was shown not to be sensitive to small variations of the serigraphy thickness.
- Measurements of the impedance in the lab were performed with the stretched wire method with matching resistors at the two ports. The impedance is deduced from the classical log formula. The measurements were done with identical experimental setup, where the alumina plates were installed after the first set of measurements of the unmodified magnet.
- Excellent agreement of the measurements with the prediction from the MKP-L impedance model has been observed in the measurements, validating the shielding effect resulting in a factor 10 reduction of the beam induced heating for LHC type beams.
- Carlo is in contact with Mike for checking if the modifications in the mechanical design for solving the HV issue reported by Mike would impact the impedance.
- Elena added that the modification of the MKP-L is also improving the longitudinal beam stability, in particular if all the MKPs (inlcuding the MKP-S) would be serigraphed. However, a careful study of the impact on the transverse beam stability would be required.
(F. Velotti)
- A tool has been developed using available data to predict the temperature evolution as input during the scrubbing runs to keep the temperature below critical limits. The available data relies on the PT100 measurements at the ground plate of the MKP-L. Neural networks have been trained using data from scrubbing cycles, in particular intensity, bunch length and MKP-L temperature during periods of continuous beam availability.
- Initial tests with different time series neural nets (LSTMs) were not giving good enough results. Refinements have been implemented taking into account not only the historic evolution but also other features at the moment of predicting the future evolution. This significantly improved the model when tested on completely unseen data. For comparison, also a Bayesian approach was tested however not achieving the same performance.
- The new model was used to predict the temperature evolution during the scrubbing with 1.5e11 p/b with different number of batches. After 2 days of scrubbing for 10h and 14h of cool-down we would reach the MKP-L temperature limit. A scenario with 8h scrubbing and 16h of cool-down seems OK for 8 days in a row. The model can be used to study the optimal choice of the Super Cycle duty cycle and the balance between scrubbing and cool-down, and also if for example SFTPRO should be put into the Super Cycle. ACTION for Francesco and the machine coordinators to determine the optimal mode of scrubbing and clarify the best moment of switching ON the ZS for conditioning.
AOB:
- Update on protecting the wire scanners with high intensity beams (T. Levens)
- Brief initial discussion took place within BI. The BCT already publishes the intensity after the last injection. To be followed in BI how to use this information in the software to inhibit the scan if the intensity is too high. ACTION Tom to come back at a later point.
- Tom checked with James Storey who confirmed that the new BGI is covered by the CONS project.
Round table
- Kevin reported that the rephasing dry run was successful using artificial frequency. Next step is to test transactional trims and RF loops.
- Danilo is working on controlled longitudinal blow- up simulations. The noise generation as used in SPS is now available in BLonD.
- Etienne: conditioning of first MKDV magnet is difficult. Big voltage breakdowns encountered on new magnet, had to revert to DC conditioning.
- Verena: there were issues with one transformer of the main dipole being followed up. The quadrupole circuits are being commissioned and measurements of the ripple will be performed. Also the option of injecting 50 Hz harmonic is available. The injection interlocking with the BHZ 361 needs to be followed up as there are issues with a moving vacuum chamber during the pulse. A modification might have implications on the TSU.