LIU-SPS Coordination Meeting

→ Europe/Zurich
Zoom

Zoom

Zoom Meeting ID
97904172722
Host
Kevin Shing Bruce Li
Useful links
Join via phone
Zoom URL

Present: Alexandre Lasheen, Andy Butterworth, Anthony Rey, Antonio Grande Mallavia, Arthur Spierer, Brennan Goddard, Carlo Zannini, Chiara Pasquino, Christine Vollinger, Christos Zamantzas, Danilo Quartullo, David Mcfarlane, David Nisbet, Elena Chapochnikova, Eric Montesinos, Kiki Veyrunes, Etienne Carlier, Fabio Follin, Francesco Maria Velotti, Francois-Xavier Nuiry, Frank Gerigk, Gerd Kotzian, Giovanni Rumolo, Giulia Papotti, Gregoire Hagmann, Hannes Bartosik, Heiko Damerau, Ivan Karpov, Ivan Romera Ramirez , James Ridewood, Johan Dalla-Costa, Johannes Bernhard, Julie Coupard, Kevin Shing Bruce Li, Leandro Intelisano, Loic De Oliveira, Luciana Kolbeck, Maciej Suminski, Marine Gourber-Pace, Michael Schenk, Nicolas Magnin, Paul Cruikshank, Philippe Baudrenghien, Reyes Alemany Fernandez, Simon Albright, Stephane Cettour Cave, Tom Levens, Verena Kain, Wolfgang Hofle, Yannick Le Borgne, Zisou Charilaos

 

Matters arising and actions 

- ACTION - A. Butterworth: provide update on interlock interfaces along with available diagnostics (interlock tree - what triggered the dump?) - system delivery expected by March;

- ACTION - P. Baudrenghien: update simulation results with input parameters from operational scenarios, i.e., injected beam will be 2.6e11, 2.4e11 towards end of ramp; calculation for power with 10 kW outside beam segments; new algorithms for power optimization;

- ACTION - Kevin, Reyes, Giulia and Theo: look at parameter model of slip stacking to be implemented in LSA (e.g. duplicate RF voltage parameter);

- ACTION - Mike: keep following up on MKP potential vacuum issue with serigraphy upgrade;

- ACTION - Verena: test MDSH trigger of SBDS failure during injection - to be tested before beam commissioning;

- ACTION  - Verena, Johan, Kevin: logging for TT10 power converters;

- ACTION - Verena: add test of failure cases which came out of last week's talk on MP commissioning

- ACTION - WS team: get specification on max intensities / minimum emittances for the 2021 SPS beams;

- ACTION - Ivan, Danilo, Giulia: get back to OP as soon as they can provide input in updating the LSA parameter model for longitudinal blow-up

- ACTION - Kevin: reach out to WS team for input on beam commissioning planning

- ACTION - OP: 2 day TS coming up for next month, is this to be ran by David? Still under discussion... for OP to clarify

Interlocking secondary beam lines (Ivan ROMERA RAMIREZ)

  • Consolidation of North Area includes deployment of beam interlocking solution.
  • Primary beams in TT20 line are presently connected to the Ring-BIS. The interlock dumps the circulating beam in the SPS. TE-MPE is currently not responsible for the existing beam interlocks, instead it is SY-STI maintaining the present Dump Control System which has slow reaction time.
  • A risk analysis has been performed for the P42/K12 lines by secondary beam line physicists. Changes of beam trajectory may lead to damage of beam elements. The dump Control System acts on beam stoppers. The new beam interlock controller must act on the internal SPS beam dump, inhibit extraction to the North Area and act on the TAX. The truth table has been compiled be MPE.
  • For the M2 line changes on the beam trajectory or size can lead to damage of detector channels. Therefore the Beam Interlock System must be able to act on power converters of specified bending magnets but no SPS beam dump or extraction inhibit is required.
  • For the H2/H4/H6/H8 lines, the maximum accidental intensity reaching the surface building EHN1 is estimated to 2.2e10 particles. Damage to experimental detectors of NA61 and NA64-e may occurr, therefore setting the current of specified bending magnets in H2 and H4 lines to 0A is required but no SPS beam dump or extraction inhibit.
  • BIS consolidation package is being compiled in EDMS document 2459282. Proposed solution will be able to trigger beam dump in the SPS and allow/inhibit slow extraction from SPS. The deployment will rely on the new BIS v2.
  • Open questions concern the detailed interlocking configuration, the level of flexibility on interlock configuration, coordination of the BIS deployment with WIC/PC as consolidation in LS3 and LS4, ...
  • Reyes asked how this new interlock is related to the ions interlock? --> They are completely separate. ACTION Reyes and TE-MPE to clarify the features of the existing ion interlock and clarify possible cross-talk.
  • Jan asked if can we send beam of the TAX is in? --> yes, therefore we should add 2 separate lines in the truth table to account for the state of the TAX.
  • Eric pointed out that in the future we should avoid the need of masking BIC inputs for having circulating beam in the SPS (like was the case in the past, explained by Verena in her presentation).

First ideas for interlocking SPS slow extraction - Reminder from BDF proposal (Verena Kain)

  • During slow extraction the beam is put on resonance and there is not a single element (like extraction kicker for fast extraction) that could inhibit extraction.
  • If the extraction needs to be aborted, the beam needs to be dumped. Only a few elements from the North Area are equipped with fast interlocks as part of Ring BIC in BA2. There is a mixture of ring and extraction interlocks, which are all maskable as required to cope with the various operational scenarios (e.g. access in BA80 requires masking of NA extraction elements to allow producing LHC beams).
  • Possible solution is to work with "timing destinations". Idea back then was to use condition interlocking with flags generated by the "Safe Machine Parameter" SMP system as already used for LHC beams.
  • Proposal to pulse sextupoles and extraction bumpers only if destination set to NA or SHiP.
  • Next steps defined back then, but never followed up, concern the power converter interlocking (need upgraded settings check before applying functions on hardware for each cycle but for the moment the power converters do not have threshold functions, can we use FMCMs with COSE, ...).
  • Jan agrees that this is now the moment to get going on the new interlocking of the experimental areas within a small working group.
  • Jan asked what the actuators are for aborting extracion. Verena explained that it is the beam dump, but the idea is to disable the sextupoles and extraction bumpers to avoid putting the beam on resonance in the first place.
  • Eric commented that presently there are many checks in SIS. Jan comments that this is not as safe as a hardware interlock and therefore for the high risk cases need to be done in hardware interlocks. 
  • ACTION BIS team (TE-MPE) to launch a working group involving OP and the EA physicist, and come back to present here in a few months.

Presentation of mandate and plans for PS2SPS transfer WG (Alexendre Lasheen)

  • The issue of losses at PS-to-SPS transfer was already subject of working groups in the past. The new working group aims at performing studies with beam in view of reducing losses at SPS injection, benchmark simulations to improve understanding, define reference settings, re-evaluate additional measures in case the losses cannot be kept inside the budgets, agree on prioritization.
  • The kick-off meeting is planned for week 13, the meeting frequency will be adjusted depending on need and progress. The starting members include colleagues from SY-RF, SY-ABT, BE-ABP and BE-OP.
  • The plan for 2021 is to refine the simulation studies as presented in one of the last meetings here, demonstrate that improved bunch rotation reduce losses as expected, quantify contribution of longitudinal halo, preliminary MDs with high intensity
  • Beyond 2021 the idea is to gradually increase intensity to full LIU beam intensity. An important task for the working group will be to provide input and needs for alternative measures and hardware installation as discussed at the LIU workshop in Montreux in 2020 (concerning for example the dedicated Landau RF system in the PS and the collimation system in the SPS).
  • Although the LIU intensities will not be reached this year, the aim is nevertheless to perform studies with high intensity. Francesco informed that the intensities 1.7e11 p/b at 450 GeV for 288 bunches is compatible with the presently degraded beam dump kicker performance. Also the fixed target beams are acceptable up to 4e13 ppp.
  • Elena pointed out that also the capture losses need to be included in the evaluation of the loss budgets, not only "injection losses".
  • Elena also asked if beams other than LHC should be treated as part of the working group. Heiko commented that the transfer for FT beams has completely different issues. Alexandre and the working group members will  come up with a proposal - could also be based on the first observations with beam after the upgrade.

 

Round table

  • Verena: preparation for beam is progressing, a few things from RF and BI still to be sorted out, TPSC4 needs to be replaced as it is blocked and positioning system is damaged, plan is to inject on 12. April,
  • Danilo started using the new SPS momentum program and the particle distribution with rotated bunches from the PS in the simulations for the controlled longitudinal blow-up.
  • working on commissioning of BETS to fine tune tracking curve at low energy, first test from CCC next week. Need to understand what happened with the TPSC4 as it seems the problem is inside vacuum.
  • Francesco: The estimation of QF field changes depending on the supercycle composition seems to be working for the data available, to be tested with beam. He will give a presentation in the next meeting.
  • Reyes: this week the LEIR injection transfer line BPMs have been commissioned, some issues have been resolved allowing for 7 out of 9 BPMs are working.  
There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.