JCOP FWWG Meeting 14 December 2021
Indico: https://indico.cern.ch/event/1097729/
Participants: Michael Ludwig, Piero, Geraldine Thomas, Piotr Golonka, Luís, Mateusz Lechman, bfarnham, Mariusz Suder, Riku-Pekka Silvola, Clara Gaspar, Stefan Schlenker, Frank Glege, Cristina Vazquez Velez, pnikiel, Wassef Karimeh, Alexander Kurepin, Paris Moschovakos, Fernando Varela, LuisGC
CAN Status and News (presented by Geraldine and Michael)
- ATLAS: what is it that stands out in Peak's diagnostic, is it Windows only?
- Yes, it is Windows only, details in CanModule doc;
- the Peak's API has the USB diagnostic, something that with SocketCAN would not be possible...
- ATLAS: clarify about drivers on Linux: one of the modules that are loaded is a standard Linux module, not a dedicated driver
- ATLAS: there is a couple of 0.5 Mbit installations; some VME crates even 1Mb/s
- ATLAS: what is that superior thing that Anagate would offer in terms of improved diags that are promised?
- tells number of clients connected (should usually be one...), TX/RX, detailed error logs with error texts (downloadable and also available by the API), port settings - available over a web interface
- option to keep the operational status after a power-cut
- is there diags for unbalanced termination, impedance, short-circuits, etc (things like a CAN analyser would show)? Haven't seen it yet, but there will be transmitter errors... the others has not so far been clarified
- CMS: adapter cables are a no-go, because we really need a tidy installation... CMS has dedicated PCBs, etc for that already. If there is no space for sub-D9, maybe stacked sub-D connectors or WAGO could be used? We should insist on what they've actually already provided...
- LHCb: did you try to ask Systec with the same requirements? After all, the last time they produced the modules especially for CERN... Maybe we could get competition play?
- Tried to contact them, got no reply... Last time they were contacted there was not much they offered. Will try once again...
- ALICE: Support for CMS idea with WAGO connectors to quickly replace the gateways in future
- ATLAS: Support for having another vendor
- ATLAS asked Systec already some time ago, but the offer was not that attractive (sharing dev costs).
- Actually KVASER was also interested in CERN needs, offering custom design. One could try to follow this lead and avoid vendor lock-in
- ATLAS: support the requirement for connectors - it is a must have due to rack space. Adapters are not really an option...
- ATLAS: very important to do tests with real nodes (in realistic scenario)
- Geraldine acknowledges that the possibility to conduct tests in the full-scale production systems in CMS have been extremely useful
OPC-UA in SCADA part of the JCOP Framework (presented by Ben and Mariusz)
- CMS: support for having the functions for creating/modifying the OPC-UA subscriptions and connections; even though CMS have their own library too
- ATLAS: could the problem of transformation be resolved on the OPCUA Server type? Use Double consistently in the OPC Server instead of Float, and it should be fine! To be reviewed internally with Ben
- ATLAS: the library to handle the OPCUA Connections/subscriptions is already done, focusing on the core needs of ATLAS. It has few rather non-generic parts: standardizes on some alarms, or descriptions, etc, yet could be a starting point to develop something that could be used in the JCOP Framework. It is not a large library.
- ALICE: uses mostly standard setups with 1-to-1 OPC Server to OPC driver for the time being, but the option is very interesting
- LHCb: similarly - the option looks interesting, even though in majority there are standard 1-to-1 setups for the time being
AOB
- none
- this was he last JCOP FWWG Meeting in 2021. Have a good Christmas/NewYear and looking forward to meet you in January 2022 (topic and date of the meeting will be announced)
There are minutes attached to this event.
Show them.