JCOP Framework Working Group Meeting
15 April 2025
INDICO: https://indico.cern.ch/event/1524169/
FwDevice+: proposal of modernisation of the JCOP Framework Device Model
- See slides and code samples attached to the presentation.
- Fernando: what is a device property? It is a datapoint element.
- Fernando: signature of addProperty seems to be complex and contain a long list of parameters; will it be future proof? Actually, it is very simple: it is a DPE name followed by the va_array (...) list of parameters of extendable size
- JC: would it be possible to use the builder pattern? Unfortunately not due to the limitation of CTRL++ (one cannot return a reference to the object).
- Clara: would be nice to have an easy way to integrate existing DPTs as new Framework Devices, with no need to list all the properties, but rather declare all of them to be used (and then fine-tune by adding/removing/configuring some). This is already the use case that was thought of
- Peter: timeline for the delivery in Summer? Is it OK for CMS? Clarified by Frank: CMS will need to put this activity on hold for a couple of weeks right now, hence the timing should be sufficient, in particular that CMS will not need the "full functionality" at that moment; important is to complete the conceptual design plus some initial interfaces allowing to express device models (ie what was presented as "Phase I" in the presentation).
- Frank explained the "CMS PLC Integration" project, which is at the origin of the requirement for fwDevice+, with some 300 device types that may need to be integrated. The project may be interesting for other experiments: proposed to have it presented at the JCOP FWWG. CMS would be willing to take into account the requirements of other experiments, if interested.
- Piotr clarified that as a "byproduct" of this developmentg we proceed with other consolidation&redesign tasks for fwCore, notably fwConfigs and fwDevice
Device Modelling of new CAEN SmartHV devices¶
- Question from Fernando about the timeline for integration of other devices, notably MARAPODS (Wiener devices for CMS).
At this moment the HAL libraries we got from Wiener are not sufficient to implement even an initial version of the OPC-UA Server,
which makes it impossible to start the work on SCADA integration before June.
AOB
- Maria Toms (CMS) raised the point of integration of MARAPODS devices becoming more and more urgent
- WinCC OA Service is enforcing the new sublicense agreements now; users whose institutes have not renewed the agreement yet have lost access to the Downloads pages, Developers License Server, WinCC OA licenses. Their existing 3.19 licenses will not be extended now (2nd chance at the end of April, provided the registration is regularized)
- Extension of the validity period for developers licenses: should become available as of 16th of April; users will be notified.
Next FWWG Meetings and topics to present
- 13 May 2025: fwStdUi: color theme management for the JCOP Framework and initial discussion of Framework Guidelines update
https://indico.cern.ch/event/1537123/
- CMS PLC component (to be scheduled)
- Report from the "WinCC OA Developer Days"
- DirectIO in WinCC OA
There are minutes attached to this event.
Show them.