LIU-SPS Coordination Meeting

→ Europe/Zurich
Vidyo

Vidyo

LIU-SPS Machine Coordination Meeting 15/4/2020

Present:Alexander Huschauer, Andy Butterworth, Anne Funken, Anthony Rey ,Antonio Grande Mallavia, Arthur Spierer, Brennan Goddard,Chiara Pasquino, David Mcfarlane, David Nisbet, Elena Chapochnikova, Eric Montesinos, Eric Veyrunes, Etienne Carlier ,Fabio Follin ,Francesco Maria Velotti ,François-Xavier Nuiry, Frank Gerigk, Gerd Kotzian, Giovanni Rumolo, Giulia Papotti ,Gregoire Hagmann ,Grzegorz Kruk, Hannes Bartosik , Ivan Karpov, Ivan Romera Ramirez, James Ridewood ,Johan Dalla-Costa, Jonathan Meignan, Julie Coupard, Kevin Shing Bruce Li ,Lars Jensen, Loic De Oliveira, Louis Pereira, Luciana Kolbeck, Malika Meddahi, Marine Gourber-Pace, Mauro Taborelli, Paul Cruikshank, Philippe Baudrenghien, Reyes Alemany Fernandez, Sonia Bartolome Jimenez, Stephane Cettour Cave, Sylvie Prodon, Verena Kain, Wolfgang Hofle, Yannick Le Borgne. 

Matter arising

  • MPK modeling is continuously being sorted out – how to get this into the control room is still to be decided
  • Functions generator is actively being worked on; Java beans have been released and Fabio has some first items to work with.
  • TI2 survey strategy has been presented at the LMC; ABT requests to schedule the alignment of the full line at the next occasion and, in the future, to be involved in decisions which can affect the operability of the lines. P. Collier recommends at least the visual inspection of the bellows in the line (to be discussed with VSC), to plan the H measurements of the last 350 m and then agree with ABT and SU on the realignment. He also endorses the realignment of the full line at the next YETS/EYETS (3-4 months needed assuming 2 teams of contractors)."
  • Tomography looks good to be done with what we have at the moment using existing installations and software; a brief functional spec document is being written by Giulia. This could be ready as a draft by next week.
  • Input for next RF dry runs was received yesterday; EDMS document needs to be checked first. Implementation will not be ready by next week.
  • VSC discussions are ongoing with Etienne and Chiara, no conclusion yet.
  • Question on early dump and how to make sure this is safe. Eric to discuss internally – this action is still open (ACTION: Erik to check early beam dump and integration into SIS).
  • 2 months extra for RF shutdown works has now been fully absorbed.

Draft planning for the restart & known additional delays (David)

  • Still in stage 3 due to COVID-19.
  • David went through the slides presented by Miguel in the LS2C focusing on the SPS and the impact on the schedule.
  • Staged re-opening: preparatory phase → stage1: status now → stage 2: start on May 11 (week 20) subject to shifts→ stage 3: +16 weeks free and open.
  • Moving into stage 2: detailed breakdown of gradual ramp up shown on slide 9; strong dependent on lock-down of other countries due to contractors.
  • We assume that everything resumes as if when we stopped for now; sequencing might have to be rechecked and reshuffled; additional weeks are being added to other machines; no extra time has been allocated for the SPS. This is still missing the detailed analysis on how we can and will have to progressively ramp up. Loic asked why the SPS does not have the extra weeks scheduled for returning back from the situation. David replied that the SPS did not have an explicit case where more time was requested by any group. Brennan clarified that for one of the other machines the extra two weeks actually came from the ramp down; for the SPS the present assumption for the planning is that the ramp-up will take place at full speed at time t0 in which case no extra time would be needed. A detailed analysis on actual schedule impact with input from the various groups and more accurate data on availability of contractors and end-of-lock-down dates needs to be made now, with EN-ACE driving this process (ACTION: EN-ACE to collect input from groups and establish a schedule for the re-start - give regular updates in the SPS MCM on SPS relevant items). Jonathan added that extra week for the PS was added for example due to the restart of the cooling system; Brennan mentioned that once the ramp-up is is clearer, there should be a schedule proposal by EN-ACE sent around asking for input from the different groups.

Beamline installation status (Antonio)

  • Antonio gave a quick update on the status of the different beamlines. Chiara mentioned that she had been asked by AWAKE to have the line pumped down for the experiment before 11 May; Chiara was wondering whether it is worth foreseeing the work if the ramp-up will actually be taking place much slower as there are many dependencies here. Chiara proposed to start on sectors rather where VSC is independent. Brennan mentioned that this line is indeed not the highest priority and the focus should be where urgently needed.
  • Wolfgang added that Philippe asked whether there are any changed for the ions program; Brennan clarified that the groups will have to come back and give input and clearly communicate what extra time will be needed after the ramp up. Brennan said that we are not trying to compress anything – decisions on scheduling will be made after input from the groups.
  • Verena asked by when it will be clear in which form and which safety measures will have to applied during stage 2. Brennan said this should come out this week. This should give enough time to come up with an idea on the impact on the schedules. ABT is actively working on how to came back with assumptions on safety measures; this will have to be refined with more information. EN-ACE will have to be in close contact with all the groups to take into account their input on extra time needed to redo the planning. EN-ACE will have to send around the adjusted draft to start iterating (ACTION: weekly update on the current situation and its impact for LIU-SPS to be incorporated into planning); more information should be coming up end of this week.

Final performance of MKDV (Francesco)

  • MKDV update: new SBDS in LSS5 with one additional MKDV
  • System checked in the test bed in lab – linear voltage response
  • MKDV rise time – main restriction given by SFT beam; 1.2us at 14 GeV, okay for operation, also for asymmetric batch spacing
  • MKDV swing – field for design 380 mTm → measured 400 mTm; slightly larger than design value but within tolerance
  • Empirical transfer functions made based on measurements; simulated flash-over did not show any issues with either density or aperture; Brennan mentioned that these types of analysis will need to be checked in terms of operational integration.
  • Chiara said she can give some more details numbers so that Franceso can conclude on this side.
  • Hannes wondered whether the kicks is still reduced when moving to 450 GeV/c. Francesco said that the voltage is still being clamped to reduce the dynamic range. But this has a very small effect. We are not at the 10 mm margin as we were before, so here we are much better that before.

RF power limits, update (Ivan)

  • AWAKE voltage limits could be traced back to CW power limit of 600 kW/cavity at power amplifier output.
  • Check power limits for run 3: Brennan asked if it is knows how the peak power changes if the pulse length of 11.5 us changes. Ivan said that pulse duration need to be adapted correspondingly. Eric clarified that the maximum power in any case if 1.6 MW and can never be exceeded independent of the actual requested average power.
  • Integration of power limits in LLRF system; two complementary protection systems by LLRF but also at the input of the power amplifier side for the beginning of run 3. Still to be decided how to react when power limits are exceeded (time constant, actions to be taken?).
  • AWAKE bunch rotation could be used for voltage calibration. Pulsed mode may not be available right at the start of run 3; will need to work in CW-mode. RF team looking into options to get higher voltages with short RF on time; this is under investigation.
  • LHC type cycle power limits can be obtained assuming some voltage program. Brennan was worried that 2.4 ppb is actually enough to be ramping; Elena said that at 2.5ppb they would already be at the limit. A power analysis shows that for the 4-section activities using 20s moving average, the power limits are exceeded.
  • Implementation of average power still to be clarified.
  • Philippe stressed once more that is is not only to clarify how to implement the power limits but also to decide on what actions to take. Hannes suggested to have some sort of supercycle power monitor for RF, similar to what is in place today for the mains, to at least be able to look whether this type of supercycle this is feasible in theory. Heiko suggested to have a look at some worst-case supercycle (i.e. dedicated LHC filling). Philippe said from the LLRF point of view, all acquisitions needed to compare voltage and powers should be in place. We now need RF to check internally how to deal with limit crossings and characterize the different scenarios which can then also be presented to OP and the other groups to decide on how to deal with limit crossings on the machine side (i.e., interlocks?). It was generally agreed that the equipment should always and in any case protect itself. Additional means of protection as well as protection for other clients have to be evaluated once the failure scenarios have been identified. (ACTION: RF to assess power limit crossings internally, ensure equipment protection and present failure scenarios for further checks by OP and other groups - update in 3 weeks). Greg stressed that if interlocks were needed he would need to know this asap as nothing has been foreseen so far in the hardware.

AOB 

  • David said that t0 seems to be the 18th of May… the approved list of activities to start during stage 1 has not yet been finalized

Next meeting: 22/4/2020 (Kevin)

Draft agenda

  • Roundtable
  • Status on schedule update (David)
  • RF diagnostics interface for the CCC (Luci)
  • Parameter model long. damper (Kevin)
There are minutes attached to this event. Show them.