LIU-SPS Coordination Meeting
Zoom
LIU-SPS Machine Coordination Meeting 16/09/2020
Invited: Alexander Huschauer, Andy Butterworth, Anne Funken, Anthony Rey ,Antonio Grande Mallavia, Arthur Spierer, Brennan Goddard,Chiara Pasquino, David Mcfarlane, David Nisbet, Elena Chapochnikova, Eric Montesinos, Eric Veyrunes, Etienne Carlier ,Fabio Follin ,Francesco Maria Velotti ,François-Xavier Nuiry, Frank Gerigk, Gerd Kotzian, Giovanni Rumolo, Giulia Papotti ,Gregoire Hagmann ,Grzegorz Kruk, Hannes Bartosik , Ivan Karpov, Ivan Romera Ramirez, James Ridewood ,Johan Dalla-Costa, Jonathan Meignan, Julie Coupard, Kevin Shing Bruce Li ,Lars Jensen, Loic De Oliveira, Louis Pereira, Luciana Kolbeck, Malika Meddahi, Marine Gourber-Pace, Mauro Taborelli, Paul Cruikshank, Philippe Baudrenghien, Reyes Alemany Fernandez, Sonia Bartolome Jimenez, Stephane Cettour Cave, Sylvie Prodon, Verena Kain, Wolfgang Hofle, Yannick Le Borgne.
Matters arising and actions
- Done: Kevin to clarify availability of total voltage measurement from LLRF. Confirmed from PB that this will be available in digital and analogue
- Done: Marine/Eric check with Greg whether also SIS logic provided; Eric waiting for reply from Greg --> check for end August; nothing critical, Greg is on vacation. Still no news. => SIS subscription is now ongoing; issue opened and on good track.
- Open action: Kevin still to organise discussions between OP/RF to integrate RF power interlocking with BIS/SIS/SPSQC/Big Sister, other applications. RF working on this, report expected for mid-September; Kevin suggested to discuss the operational handling of interlocks in August --> RF still preparing to finalize topic internally; will ask for reports in one month; then pick up on these. Kevin to remind RF.
- Open action: Jminuit not compatible with JDK11. Verena find other solution. Not before mid of October
- Done: Wolfgang to clarify with the LLRF team whether all HW requirements are met for 800 MHz slip stacking and whether system is ready in time for tests in 2021 => 800 MHz requirements will be checked and discussed internally within RF in preparation for the SPS MCM early October.
- Open action: Verena/IPP ensure availability of CALS in read-only mode beyond LS2. => NXCALS will be followed up in an LMC and IPP; CO is aware of request to keep CALS readable for a longer time; potential loss of data.
- Done: impact of installation of MKP-L and shorten run 2021. How much shutdown does the SPS need beyond EN/EL, BE/ICS and CV maintenance 2021/22.
- Open action: OP to check completeness of IST lists - Kevin/Verena/James/Stephane
- Open action: Brennan to check HW delivery schedule with Erk, Frank and Co.
- Open action: Verena & Co to organize meeting for SIS and XTIM distribution etc.
- Open action: Verena to release WS EDMS doc.
- Open action: Ivan and RF to check HW requirements for 800 MHz use to stabilize AWAKE beams.
- Open action: Chiara to check required ECR modification with Sonia.
- Ions requirements document sent around by Reyes; needs to be checked together with Giulia & Kevin
- Meeting with COLDEX is organized
- Add 4-5 hours mini-shifts during NA setting up week in scrubbing weeks.
News on dry-run and test progress
- Kevin presented recent results from the RFFG COAST tests; successfully entered and left coast; timing issues discovered and resolved. Turned out to be a configuration problem.
- Kevin remarked that the tests are running without hardware at the moment and are not yet full vertical slice. Brennan asked by when the HW should be available. The delivery dates were not entirely clear.
Status of SPS SE spill control (Verena)
- Spill quality control; spill micro and macro structures
- Spill micro structure improved (lower noise for acquisition)
- Improved tools and Python integration
- New BSI with new application on top if it; communication and first level analysis is available
- Bandwidth ranges selectable --> Python algorithms can also easily handle large amount of data
- Improved algorithms - OpenAi Gym environment and numerical optimizer tested; could ultimately correct all frequencies in one go; will always need a scan
- Other options - ML (not well suited) or analytical
- Francesco: do we want to use different optimizers? Verena said they can do anything, COBYLA is preferred for now but BOBYQA could also be used. Francesco asked why we do not have an output on expected spill from current (DCCT); one could add this -- ACTION: Verena to plan to add this.
- Hannes: if we assume that the component is directly related to what we have on the QD - this should also be applicable for other beams; can we use the the determined correction also for other beams and not only for FT? Right now the electronics only works if we have the SE trigger. To be investigated (ACTION: to be followed up by Hannes, Verena).
AWAKE long. beam quality studies (data from 2018 and expectations for Run 3) Heiko/Ivan
- AWAKE studies based on input from Heiko and Giulia;
- Large bunch length spreads - variation day by day; most likely caused by bunch rotations; they want more stable bunch parameters for next run;
- Bunch lengthening likely cause by instabilities for intensities above 2e11 --> bunches likely to be unstable still also after the impedance reduction campaign if no further optimization is done (minimum bunch length 1.25 ns);
- Optimization of RF voltage program during cycle making use of RF power upgrade; options for optimization: operational scans, simulations or semi-analytical calculations;
- Suggestion for using MELODY - semi-analytical calculations - from here we expect to get 1ns bunch length at flat top;
- Second option: non-adiabatic bunch rotation (as opposed to adiabatic bunch shrinking as previous option); this will require CLEBU. In this case the bunch length can be reduced down to 0.8 ns;
- ML options available to optimize bunch rotation --> can get down to 0.7 ns;
- Proposition:
- Adiabatic shrinking
- Bunch rotation + optimizers
- Elena: fixed phase for bunch shortening mode; Ivan has not optimized this as well; preliminary studies on phase shift sensitivity show that a shift can actually help;
- Giulia: commented that she does not see an easy way to increase the 800 MHz; might need to request something new.
Hysteresis modeling migration (Nico) --> postponed
SPS weaknesses post-LS2 (Verena)
- In preparation of SPS ORA; addressing SPS weaknesses;
- Brennan wondered whether one could try and put short, medium, or long term programs that would potentially tackle these items;
- Francesco asked about the stability of extraction trajectory, that this would be something that is actually ongoing, for example; the same is true for longitudinal beam quality from PS; Giulia said that there is actually preparations ongoing for a PS BQM; this is a longer term CO projects.
Round Table
- Nico: managed to make predictor run on currents; more updates next week;
- Chiara: things are going fine in tunnel but at slightly slower pace; keep a close eye in the coming 3 weeks! Discussion with EN-ACE, alignment campaign etc. Second item: in some cases installation we need some mods with respect to the ECRs, this should be updated or checked;
- David: TI2 alignment campaign update - SU will report at the LMC; is about on track;
- Reyes: due to work overload of the survey team, does not seem possible they can make the survey in LEIR before week 42, ideally should be done week 40; this will allow us to start the renovation of three magnets, 2 in EE and 1 in EI, in one go; if they cannot make it, then only the 2 EE magnets will be renovated and the EI magnet will be left for the next YETS; the problem is that to remove the EI magnet, one EE magnet will have to be removed too, and this is an enormous overhead for many groups and for the LEIR machine, since several vacuum sectors will have to be broken again; the new TT2 stripper foil system is advancing very well; a EN-STI fellow is working on this and several information exchanges has been done to define the system; a possible first layout has been already proposed.
- Lars: still need to move on with WS parameters to get it into approval.
Agenda for next meeting (23/09/2020)
- a-C coating: LS2 report Wil
- a-C coating: extrapolation to LS3 Paul
- Hysteresis modeling integration Nico