JCOP FWWG 3 Nov 2020
JCOP FWWG Meeting 3 November 2020:
ZoomIn3D: data visualization in 3D from Cleverdist
INDICO link: https://indico.cern.ch/event/969526/ , virtual meeting over zoom.
Presenter: Robert Gomez-Reino (Cleverdist)
Participants: Piotr Golonka (chairman), Fernando Varela (BE-ICS), Giulio Morpurgo (BE-ICS), Arkadiusz Maciej Homa (CMS), Clara Gaspar (LHCb), Geraldine Thomas (BE-ICS), Raul Jimenez (CMS), Jonas Arroyo (BE-ICS), Juan Manuel Pablo Rodriguez (BE-ICS), Lukas Asserladscheider (CMS), Luis Granado Cardoso (LHCb), Mariusz Suder (BE-ICS), Mateusz Lechman (ALICE), Ombretta Pinazza (ALICE), Peter Chochula (ALICE), Piero Giorgio Verdini (CMS), Rafal Kulaga (BE-ICS), Riku-Pekka Silvola (BE-ICS), Stefan Schlenker (ATLAS), Cristina Vazquez (CMS), Wassef Karimeh (CMS).
Robert Gomez-Reino, our former coleague from the CMS DCS Team and the CEO of Cleverdist presented and demonstrated the 3D visualization solution for WinCC OA called "ZoomIn3D". The web page of the product, including a short film demonstrating it may be found at : https://www.cleverdist.com/zoomin3d
The following were discussed:
- (LHCb) how complex would it be to get the geometry for the experiment visualized with this tool? The geometry needs to be exported to one of recognized file format, and then it could be loaded to the engineering tool. For sure there must be very detailed geometry descriptions for detectors used by, e.g. Geant4 (physics analysis).
- What are the largest models that it could support (related to the above). Some of geometries that it was used with contained over 15M polygons. It all depends on the level of detail being displayed. For reference, in earlier fw3DViewer experiments in CMS there used to be around 4M shapes. One should give it a try.
- Operating systems? WinCC OA version? Windows and Linux are both supported; 3.17 and 3.16 should be supported.
- Does it depend on any other product of Cleverdist (e.g. smartnodes)? No, it is "standalone" and ready for immediate integration
- (CMS Safety): a similar type of views for the web browser have recently been developed. What are the underpinning technologies? The backend uses the OGRE3D open source 3D Graphics engine (and might be replaced later). Then comes all the possible importers used to compile various geometry file formats into optimized representations - they use different techniques
- What are the supported geometry file formats? Is CATIA3d file format supported? Experience show that engineering tools usually have the option to export to a "neutral" and inter-operable format, and that works pretty well. And also the list of supported file formats/importers grow. RGR to send the list of supported formats to CERN.
- Could CERN get/try/use it? The "evaluation" versions with 30-day license will be made available through the BE-ICS to interested users. Then we may discuss how to arrange it for the use in production, if anyone would need it. Feedback concerning the tool could be transmitted to the company through FVR and PG (BE-ICS).
- Is there any other Cleverdist solution that could be interesting for CERN? Cleverdist releases series of products, described on the web page, yet they are namely for manufacturing. To be reviewed.
- RGR: is there any interest in collaboration on the use of ML for predictibe maintenance? CERN already works on that through the openlab collaboration with Siemens. Idea: how about cleverdist joining CERN openlab (to be clarified with RGR, FVR later).
AOB:
- WinCC OA 3.18 release plan for April is maintained, with lots of features already implemented. Initial test build will be evaluated by BE-ICS once received, and the results will be made known to the JCOP Community.