Review of BLonD manuscript
Ivan: Faster induced-voltage calculation 
	- Application: FCC with large circumference, 10000s of bunches
	
		- 10 B macro particles needed if scaling directly
 
		- Transverse feedback studies done in 2018 with PyHEADTAIL
 
	
	 
	- Present BLonD implementations
	
		- Freq domain: circular convolution -> periodic result, any impedance model; uniform sampling needed
 
		- Time domain: linear convolution with zero padding, any impedance model; uniform sampling needed
 
		- Resonator impedance: matrix multiplication -> non-uniform sampling needed, but N^2 complexity
 
		- Ideally, want to have non-uniform implementation, but with Nlog(N) complexity
 
	
	 
	- Compressed convolution by ABP
	
		- Drawback: double number of slices needed
 
		- For multi-turn wake, empty bucket sampling needed
 
	
	 
	- How does it work?
	
		- Induced voltage only needed on the points where the line density is not zero
 
		- Introducing a MASKING of the data -> can cut the wakefield data
 
		- Calculate convolution on compressed data
		
			- For the relevant bins, the results are the same
 
			- For other locations, data is not correct => CANNOT use it for beam with LOSSES
 
		
		 
	
	 
	- Performance test:
	
		- Full convolution with 5 bucket bunch spacing vs. full conv with 15 bucket bunch spacing vs compressed convolution: compressed convolution performs best of all
 
		- The smaller the spacing, the less the improvement
 
	
	 
	- Remarks on wake calculation
	
		- N. Mounet: exact analytical wake calculation can be approximated by cubic Hermitian interpolation
		
			- example: resistive wall impedance is not correctly represented by standard FFT, while analytical approximation is correct
 
		
		 
		- Drawback: analytical expression of the impedance needed
		
			- For cases where the impedance is known, but wake cannot be calculated
 
		
		 
	
	 
	- Implementation in BLonD: Ivan will make a first implementation
	
		- Already existing SparseSlicing objects
		
			- Issue reported by Markus in C++ implementation
 
		
		 
	
	 
	- Mihaly: how about using non-uniform FFT?
 
             
            
                
                    There are minutes attached to this event.
                    
Show them.