Hadronic calibration workshop 2009

Europe/Zurich
Foz do Arelho (Portugal)

Foz do Arelho (Portugal)

Jimmy Proudfoot (High Energy Physics Division), Tancredi Carli (CERN)
Description
This workshop reviews the status of the Jet and Etmiss reconstruction and calibration in the Atlas experiment. The focus of the workshop is to define the calibration and analysis strategies of the 2010 data. Future directions will be discussed. The format of the workshop follows the tradition of the previous workshops with emphasis on discussions. Based on the material submitted, the session conveners will guide the discussion. Overall schedule: * Tuesday 23: Lectures and introductions to QCD, energy reconstruction and hadronic calibration in ATLAS. It is recommended that all people who are not yet familiar with the Atlas hadronic calibration strategies attend these lectures. In particular, students and new-comers are invited. * Wednesday 24: Test-beam, detector performance, local hadron calibration and jet calibration and long term Monte Carlo tuning * Thursday 25: Will be devoted to establish the jet energy scale in the 2010 data * Friday 26: Will discuss the reconstruction and calibration of the missing transverse energy including results from the 2008/9 commisioning data. Also DPD and trigger aspects will be discussed. * Saturday 27: Will summarise the work-shop and discuss future directions. A workshop review panel will work-out and present action items, identify open points and given recommendations. For all pratical information see: https://web.lip.pt/atlas-workshop/index.php The detailed topics and points to be discussed for each session can be found on https://twiki.cern.ch/twiki/bin/view/AtlasProtected/HadronicCalibrationWorkshop09 Please, submit material directly to the agenda. Look at the Example test session on Wednesday morning 6:00-8:00. The modification password is jetrec
    • 1
      A short introduction to QCD
      Speaker: Tancredi Carli (CERN)
      Slides
      • a) Some notes for everybody interested to go through some instructive calculations
        Slides
    • 2
      Modern Monte Carlo Event Generators: Opportunities and Limitations
      Speaker: Stefan Hoeche (Uni Zuerich)
      Slides
    • 10:45
      coffee break
    • 3
      Modelling minimum bias events and the underlying event
      Speaker: Dr Stefan Hoeche (Uni Zuerich)
      Slides
    • 4
      Hadronic shower model simulation in G4
      Speaker: Dr John Apostolakis (CERN)
      Slides
    • 12:30
      lunch break
    • 5
      Energy reconstruction in the calorimeter
      Speaker: Manuella Vincter (Carleton University)
      Lots of slides...
    • 6
      Jet and Etmiss reconstruction and calibration - part I
      Speaker: Peter Loch (University of Arizona)
      Slides
      Slides (PDF)
    • 15:30
      coffee break
    • 7
      Jet and Etmiss reconstruction and calibration - part II
      Speaker: Peter Loch (University of Arizona)
    • 8
      An introduction to modern jet algorithms
      Speaker: Paolo Francavilla (Unknown)
      Slides
    • 9
      Summary of the recent ATLAS jet algorithm studies
      Speaker: Sebastian Eckweiler
      Slides
    • 10
      The jet software from a user point of view
      Speaker: Kerstin Perez (Columbia University)
      Slides
    • Welcome drink
    • Welcome by the organisers
    • Goals of the workshop
      slides
      • 11
        Goals - Bullet Points
        Paper
      • 12
        Workshop Goals
        Speaker: Jimmy Proudfoot (High Energy Physics Division)
        more information
    • Test-beam and detector performance
      • 13
        Introduction and Overview of session
      • 14
        EM scale status and HV corrections
        Speaker: Tomas Davidek (Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics)
        Slides
        • a) Material: HV corrections in LAr (HEC)
          Speaker: Peter Schacht (MPI)
          Slides
      • 15
        EM scale in forward calo's (in situ)
        Speaker: Mohamed Aharrouche (Mainz)
        Slides
      • 16
        ATLAS performance: noise status and overall quality
        Speaker: Irene Vichou (U of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign)
        Slides
        • a) Material: Noise status in LAr
          Speaker: Elisabeth Petit (Centre de Physique des Particules de Marseille (CPPM)-Universite)
          Slides
        • b) Material: Calo noise measurement and Topocluster Performance
          Speaker: Hideki Okawa (Univ. of Tokyo)
          Slides
        • c) Material: TileCal non-Gaussian noise implementation
          Speakers: Andrei Artamonov (ANL), Luca Fiorini (IFAE)
          Slides
          text
        • d) Material: Lar hardware issues
          Speaker: Luis Hervas (CERN)
          Slides
        • e) Material: Lar areas with no response and s/w plans
          Speaker: Guillaume Unal
          text
      • 17
        TB vs. MC comparison in endcaps
        Speaker: Peter Schacht (MPI)
        • a) Material: HEC standalone
          Speakers: Andrei Kiryunin (Werner-Heisenberg-Institut), Mr Pavol Strizenec (IEP)
          additional slides
          Slides
        • b) Material: CTB EMEC/HEC/FCAL
          Speaker: Mr Pavol Strizenec (IEP)
          more information
          Slides
        • c) Material: FCAL2003
          Speaker: Peter Krieger (University of Toronto)
          Slides
        • d) Material: FCAL2003, inner edge
          Speaker: Louise Heelan (Carleton University)
          Slides
        • e) Material: FCAL2003 backup slides
          Speaker: Peter Krieger (University of Toronto)
          Slides
      • 18
        CTB EMEC/HEC/FCAL TB vs. MC
        Speaker: Mr Pavol Strizenec (IEP)
      • 19
        TB vs. MC comparison in barrel
        Speaker: Tomas Davidek (Institute of Particle and Nuclear Physics)
        Slides
        • a) Material: CTB2004 comparison with MC
          Speaker: Tancredi Carli (CERN)
          Slides
        • b) Material: Tilecal standalone data vs MC
          Speaker: Margar Simonyan (lapp-Laboratoire d'Annecy-le-Vieux de Physique des Particules-In)
          Slides
        • c) Tilecal standalone data vs MC, G4.9.3beta
          Speakers: Margar Simonyan (lapp-Laboratoire d'Annecy-le-Vieux de Physique des Particules-In), Tancredi Carli (CERN)
          Slides
    • 11:00
      coffee break
    • Tuning of simulation and detector description
      • 20
        Introduction and overview of E/p measurement achievements and limitations for hadrons in CDF
        Speaker: Dr Beate Heinemann (LBNL and UC Berkeley)
        Slides
      • 21
        Tuning of simulation and detector description for electrons and photons: what is relevant to jet/ETmiss?
        Speaker: Daniel Froidevaux (CERN)
        Slides
      • 22
        Tuning of G4 physics and detector description: what can be done with single pions?
        Speaker: Naoko Kanaya (University of Tokyo / ICEPP)
        Slides
      • 23
        What can be learned from hadron E/p measurements with early data?
        Speaker: Nadia Davidson (University of Melbourne)
        Slides
    • 13:00
      lunch break
    • Local hadron calibration
      • 24
        Intoduction and Session Guide
        Speaker: Sven Menke (Max-Planck-Institut fur Physik)
        Slides
      • 25
        Material submitted : Local Hadron Calibration Performance for Jet reconstruction
        Speaker: Paola Giovannini (Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physik Muenchen)
        Slides
      • 26
        Material submitted: Description of Topological Cluster Moment in the Barrel CTB
        Speaker: Tancredi Carli (CERN)
        Slides
      • 27
        Material: Charged pion and electron moments from CTB2004 data
        Speaker: Pavol Strizenec (IEPSAS-Kosice)
      • 28
        Material: Jet Moment Studies
        Speaker: Andreas Jantsch (Max-Planck-Institut fรผr Physik)
        Backup
        Backup Serena
        Slides
      • 29
        Material: Performance update for single pions
        Speaker: Guennadi Pospelov (MPI fuer Physik)
        Slides
      • 30
        Material submitted: Energy Flow using TopoClusters and Local Hadron Calibration
        Speaker: Mark Hodgkinson (Department of Physics and Astronomy-University of Sheffield-Unkn)
        Slides
      • 31
        Material: Reconstruction of Topoclusters with Pileup
        Speaker: Christoph Ruwiedel (Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms Universitaet Bonn)
        Slides
    • 16:00
      coffee break
    • Cell energy density weighting for jet calibration
      • 32
        Summary by the conveners
        pictures
        Slides
      • 33
        Material: Layer calibration, adding energy constraint to minimization and difference between H1 fine and coarse granularity
        belen_layer_cell_EV
    • buffet
    • Discussion forum
      Slides
    • Jet energy scale - Part I

      Overview of the the Jet energy scale session
      o Calibration schemes
      o Factorized corrections
      o Tests and systematics

      Inputs to jet reconstruction:
      o towers
      o topo-towers
      o clusters

      Pile-up offset correction

      • 34
        Introduction
        overview and status of jet energy scale corrections
        Speaker: Ariel Schwartzman (SLAC)
        Slides
      • 35
        Tower Noise Removal
        Speaker: Michele Petteni (SFU)
        Slides
      • 36
        Noise suppression: topo-tower noise suppression optimization
        Speaker: David W. Miller (SLAC)
        Slides
      • 37
        Inputs to jet reconstruction: towers, clusters and topo-towers
        Speaker: David W. Miller (SLAC)
        Slides
      • 38
        Baseline offset correction: event / detector based
        Speaker: David W. Miller (SLAC)
        Slides
    • 11:00
      coffee break
    • Jet energy scale: Part II

      Jet corrections: Relative Eta correction across the calorimeter

      * Description of technique (traditional, 2D), event selection, trigger
      * Performance at the EM scale, after cell-density, after local hadron
      * Validation + pile-up effect
      * Systematic uncertainties
      

      Jet corrections: Absolute response

      * Corrections based on MC
            o Simple pT-Eta correction
            o Jet-moment corrections 
      * Corrections based on Data
            o Z/gamma+jet balance
            o Missing pT fraction (MPF)
      * Extrapolation to high Pt
      
      • 39
        Introduction/Summary
        Speaker: Mario Martinez-Perez (IFAE-Barcelona)
        Slides
      • 40
        Absolute Correction (Pt and Eta) using MonteCarlo
        • a) Material: Eta-dependent response corrections
          Speaker: Pavel Weber (Heidelberg University)
          Slides
        • b) Material: Simple Eta-pT calibration (Numerical Inversion)
          Speaker: David Lopez Mateos (Columbia University)
          Paper
          Slides
        • c) Material: Constituents Based Jet Level Corrections
          Speaker: Andreas Jantsch (Max-Planck-Institut fรผr Physik)
          Slides
        • d) Material submitted: Resolution with non linear calorimeter response
          Speaker: Paola Giovannini (Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physik Muenchen)
          more information
          Slides
      • 41
        Extrapolation to large Pt
        • a) Material: Bootstrapping the JES to High pT
          Speaker: Frederik Ruehr (Kirchhoff-Institut fuer Physik (KIP)-Ruprecht-Karls-Universitaet)
          Slides
        • b) Material: Extrapolation to High PT
          Slides
      • 42
        gamma+Jet Balance
        • a) Material I : photon+Jet Balance
          Speakers: Eric Feng (University of Chicago), Dr Georgios Choudalakis (University of Chicago, Enrico Fermi Institute)
          Slides
        • b) Material II: photon-jet balance
          Speaker: Andrea Messina (CERN)
          Slides
        • c) Material III: photon+jet balance (an alternative)
          Speaker: Pierre Savard (Department of Physics - University of Toronto)
          Slides
        • d) gamma/Z+jets balance
          Speaker: Sergei Chekanov (HEP division (ANL))
          Paper
        • e) Material: jet calibration with photon + jet balancing
          Speaker: Michele Cascella (INFN, Sezione di Pisa)
          Slides
      • 43
        On MPF Method
        • a) Material: Absolute energy scale with missing energy projection fraction
          Speaker: Teresa Michelle SPREITZER
          Slides
        • b) Material: Phi Asymmetries in the MPF Method
          Speaker: Gareth BROWN
          Slides
      • 44
        Material: jet calibration with photon + jet balancing
        Speaker: Michele Cascella (INFN, Sezione di Pisa-Unknown-Unknown)
        Paper
        Slides
      • 45
        Material submitted: Resolution with non linear calorimeter response
        Speaker: Paola Giovannini (Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physik Muenchen)
        Back up Material
        Slides
      • 46
        Material: Absolute energy scale with missing energy projection fraction
        Speaker: Teresa Michelle Spreitzer (Simon Fraser University-Unknown-Unknown)
        Slides
      • 47
        Material: Azimuthal Intercalibration for TileCal
        Speaker: Maria Papadopoulou (National Technical Univ. of Athens)
        Slides
      • 48
        Material: Bootstrapping the JES to High pT
        Speaker: Frederik Ruehr (Kirchhoff-Institut fuer Physik (KIP)-Ruprecht-Karls-Universitaet)
        Slides
      • 49
        Material: Constituents Based Jet Level Corrections
        Speaker: Andreas Jantsch (Max-Planck-Institut fรผr Physik)
        Slides
      • 50
        Material: Eta-dependent response corrections
        Speaker: Mr Pavel Weber (Heidelberg University)
        Slides
      • 51
        Material: Extrapolation to High PT
        Speaker: Koji Terashi (University of Tokyo)
        Slides
      • 52
        Material: Gamma+jet balance
        Speaker: Sergei Chekanov (HEP division (ANL))
        Paper
      • 53
        Material: Phi Asymmetries in the MPF Method
        Speaker: Gareth Brown
        Slides
      • 54
        Material: Photon-Jet balance
        Speakers: Eric Feng (University of Chicago), Dr Georgios Choudalakis (University of Chicago, Enrico Fermi Institute)
        Slides
      • 55
        Material: photon-jet balance
        Speaker: Andrea Messina (CERN)
        Slides
      • 56
        Material: Photon-Jet Balance Study: An Alternative
        Speakers: Pierre Savard (Department of Physics - University of Toronto), SL Cheung (University of Toronto)
        Slides
      • 57
        Material: Simple Eta-pT calibration (Numerical Inversion)
        Speaker: David Lopez Mateos (Columbia University)
        Paper
        Slides
      • 58
        Material: Z+jet balance
        Speaker: Sergei Chekanov (HEP division (ANL))
        Paper
    • 13:00
      lunch break
    • Jet energy scale: Part III

      Jet corrections: Out-of-cone corrections

      * EM scale, H1 and LC jets
      * Systematic uncertainties
      * Etmiss consistency
      

      Jet corrections: configurations with close by jets

      * Present status and future strategy
      

      Jet corrections: Order of corrections
      Closure tests

      * W-mass constrained in top pairs
      * gamma/Z-balance
      * Drell-Yan pairs
      * Jet shapes : Data-MC comparison
      
      slides
      Slides
      • 59
        Basic Questions on Systematics
        Speaker: Andreas Jantsch (Max-Planck-Institut fรผr Physik)
        Slides
      • 60
        Material: Data-Driven Jet Efficiency
        Speaker: Stephanie Majewski (Department of Physics-Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL))
        Slides
      • 61
        Material: Flavor dependence on the JES
        Speakers: Hongbo Liao (Institute of High Energy Physics (IHEP)-Chinese Academy of Scien), Mr Jรฉrรดme Schwindling (CEA saclay)
        Slides
      • 62
        Material: Hadronic Calibration of Semileptonic b-jets
        Speaker: David Lopez Mateos (Columbia University)
        Slides
      • 63
        Material: Implementation of Primary Particle ID for Jet Studies
        Speaker: Guennadi Pospelov (MPI fuer Physik)
        Slides
      • 64
        Material: JES correction by close by jets
        Speakers: Dennis Hellmich (Universitรคt Bonn, Physikalisches Institut), Marc-Andre Pleier (Rheinische-Friedrich-Wilhelms- Univ.-Univ. Bonn, Physikalisches)
        Slides
      • 65
        Material: Jet energy resolution measurement
        Speaker: Gaston L. Romeo (UBA)
        Slides
      • 66
        Material: Study on Jet Shapes
        Speaker: Francesc (et. al.,) Vives (IFAE-Barcelona)
        Slides
      • 67
        Material: Test Jet Reconstruction on Wmass
        Speakers: Belen Salvachua (Argonne National Laboratory (ANL)), Jimmy Proudfoot (High Energy Physics Division)
        Paper
      • 68
        Material: Tests of jet energy scale
        Speakers: Mrs Chiara Roda (UNIVERSITY AND INFN OF PISA), Vincent Francois Giangiobbe (Dipartimento di Fisica-Universita degli Studi di Pisa-Universita)
        Paper
        Slides
    • 16:00
      lunch break
    • Jet energy scale: Part IV

      Jet energy resolution improvement after calibration

      * Jet vertex fraction event-by-event pile-up correction
      * Layer energy fraction corrections
      * Track-based response corrections
      

      Methodology to establish a systematic jet energy scale uncertainty

      • 69
        Introduction
        Speaker: Ariel Schwartzman (SLAC)
        Slides
      • 70
        Material: Layer Energy Fraction Corrections
        Speaker: David Lopez Mateos (Columbia University)
        Paper
        Slides
      • 71
        Material: track-based response correction
        Speaker: Gaston L. Romeo (UBA)
        Slides
      • 72
        Material: JVF pile-up jet energy corrections
        Speaker: David W. Miller (SLAC)
        Slides
      • 73
        Thoughts on Jet Systematics
        Speaker: Jimmy Proudfoot (High Energy Physics Division)
        Slides
      • 74
        Thoughts on systematics (II)
        Speaker: Dr Mario Martinez-Perez (IFAE-Barcelona)
        Slides
    • workshop dinner
    • Discussion forum
      Slides
    • Before collision data: Cosmic clean-up and cell masking (and Data Quality and monitoring issues)
      • 75
        Material: A study of correlation between track based MET and Calo based MET using cosmic data
        Speaker: Zhijun Liang
        Slides
      • 76
        Material: Beam-Background Analysis in Jet/Etmiss Signatures
        Speaker: Bernhard Meirose Da Silva Costa (Albert-Ludwigs-Universitaet Freiburg-Unknown-Unknown)
        Slides
        • a) Background: From April 27 DP Taskforce
          Slides
        • b) Background: From February 11 Jet/EtMiss Phone
          Slides
      • 77
        Material: CaloMonitoring Status and Plans
        Speaker: Haleh Hadavand (Southern Methodist University)
        Slides
      • 78
        Material: Calorimetric Etmiss with random and cosmic data
        Speaker: Elisabeth Petit (Centre de Physique des Particules de Marseille (CPPM)-Universite)
        Slides
      • 79
        Material: Commissioning of Jet/ETmiss with Cosmic Data & Their Clean-up
        Speaker: Hideki Okawa (Univ. of Tokyo)
        Slides
      • 80
        Material: Cosmics as a background to โ€˜Stopped Gluinosโ€™
        Speaker: Paul Jackson (SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory)
        Slides
      • 81
        Material: Jet/MET Data Quality Group
        Speakers: Jean-Raphael Lessard (University of Victoria), Michele Consonni (Radboud University Nijmegen-Unknown-Unknown)
        Slides
      • 82
        Material: Large Scale MET Cosmic Study
        Speaker: Baharak Fatholahzadeh (Unknown)
        Paper
        Slides
      • 83
        Material: Rejection of cosmics with real data
        Speaker: Yingchun Zhu (Department of Physics-University of Wisconsin)
        Slides
      • 84
        Material: TileCal results with cosmics and first beams
        Speaker: Matteo Volpi (IFAE - Institut de Fรญsica d'Altes Energies-Universitat Autรฒnoma)
        Slides
      • 85
        Material: Tower jets : multiplicity
        Speaker: Mr Nikola Makovec (LAL-Orsay)
        Slides
      • 86
        Material: Using the quality factor to remove bad objects (update)
        Speaker: Francois Niedercorn (Lab. de l'Accelerateur Lineaire (IN2P3) (LAL)-Universite de Pari)
        Slides
      • 87
        Comprehensive Session Slides: Before Collision Data
        Speaker: Adam Gibson (University of Toronto)
        Slides
    • 11:00
      coffee break
    • MET calibration with first collisions
      • 88
        From basic ETmiss to Refined Calibration, step by step procedure
        Speaker: Silvia Resconi (Dipartimento di Fisica)
        • a) Local Hadron Calibration Performance for MET reconstruction
          Speaker: Paola Giovannini (Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physik-Unknown-Unknown)
          Slides
      • 89
        Track based missing ET
        Speaker: Zhijun Liang
        Slides
      • 90
        MET with pile-up
        Speaker: Michele Consonni (Laboratoire d'Annecy-le-Vieux de Physique des Particules (LAPP))
        Slides
      • 91
        MET tails
        • a) Punch-through detection using โ€˜Muon Showersโ€™
          Speaker: Johan Lundberg (Conseil Europeen Recherche Nucl. (CERN)-Unknown-Unknown)
          Slides
        • b) MET tails in dijet events
          Speaker: David Berge
        • c) Predicting MET Tails in Early Data
          Speaker: Lorraine Courneyea (University of Victoria)
          Slides
    • 13:00
      lunch break
    • In-situ Etmiss performance and closure with first 10-100 pb^-1
      • 92
        Overview of MET Validation with 10 to 100 pb-1
        Speaker: Richard Teuscher (Toronto)
        Slides
      • 93
        Material: EtMiss scale in Ztautau
        Speaker: Donatella Cantore-Cavalli (Dipartimento di Fisica)
      • 94
        Material: Etmiss acceptance
        Speaker: Ellie Dobson (Oxford University)
        Slides
      • 95
        Material: In-situ MET Performance from W->mu nu decay
        Speaker: Shimpei Yamamoto (Univ. of Tokyo)
        Slides
      • 96
        Material: Neutrinofication using AOD
        Speaker: Dr Siragusa Giovanni (Universitaet Mainz)
        Slides
      • 97
        Material: Resolution in Etmiss
        Speaker: Ellie Dobson (Oxford University)
        Slides
      • 98
        Material: Z->ee MET bias and new Ref term calibrations
        Speaker: Eric Williams (Columbia University)
        Slides
      • 99
        Material: Zee overview
        Speaker: Ellie Dobson (Oxford University)
        Slides
      • 100
        Material: Zmumu diagnostic plot
        Speaker: Adam Yurkewicz (Stony Brook)
        Slides
      • 101
        Material:Etmiss in ttbar
        Speaker: Manouk Rijpstra (NIKHEF)
        Slides
      • 102
        Material: Measurement of Jet Response Tails
        Speaker: Robert Duxfield (Department of Physics)
        Slides
      • 103
        Missing Transverse Energy Requirements from SUSY Searches
        Speaker: Daniel Tovey (Department of Physics and Astronomy-University of Sheffield-Unkn)
        Slides
    • 16:00
      coffee break
    • Data analysis using DPD and triggers
      • 104
        Introduction
        Speakers: Koji Terashi (University of Tokyo), Thorsten Wengler (University of Manchester)
        Slides
      • 105
        Material submitted : Local Hadron Calibration tests with Performace DPDs
        Speaker: Paola Giovannini (Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physik Muenchen)
        Back up Material
        Slides
      • 106
        Material: photon-jet DPDs
        Speaker: Andrea Messina (CERN)
        Slides
    • Towards one calibration scheme
      Chiara & Peter slides
      P. Loch's notes (metric for comparisons etc.)
      • 107
        Slides for discussion
        Speakers: Jimmy Proudfoot (High Energy Physics Division), Tancredi Carli (CERN)
        Slides
      • 108
        Peter&Chiaras toughts
        Speaker: Peter Loch (University of Arizona)
        Slides
    • 11:00
      coffee break
    • Conclusion of the workshop: Open Issues & Action items
      paper
      • 109
        Concluding discussion on Test-beam, Monte Carlo and Cell-level Calibration
        Speaker: Majorie Shapiro
      • 110
        Concluding discussion on Jet Energy Scale
        Speaker: Robert Kehoe (Southern Methodist University)
        Slides
      • 111
        Concluding discussion on Commissioning, Etmiss and DPD
        Speaker: Katsuo Tokushuku (High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (KEK))
        Slides
      • 112
        Concluding discussion on Toward One Calibration, and the RP Report
        Speaker: Robert Kehoe (Southern Methodist University)
        Slides
    • Tutorial on jet software
      slides