Towards a next space probe for CMB observations and cosmic origins exploration

from Tuesday, May 17, 2016 (9:00 AM) to Friday, May 20, 2016 (4:00 PM)
CERN (222/R-001)

        : Sessions
    /     : Talks
        : Breaks
May 17, 2016
May 18, 2016
May 19, 2016
May 20, 2016
AM
9:00 AM
Introduction (until 10:20 AM)
9:00 AM CERN's Director for Research and Computing : Welcome - Eckhard Elsen (CERN)  
9:10 AM Welcome from the LOC - Enrico Chesta (CERN)  
9:15 AM Objectives of the workshop (10'+5) - Jacques Delabrouille (CNRS, Laboratoire APC, Paris)  
9:30 AM Scientific introduction (15'+5) - Francois Bouchet (Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris)  
9:50 AM Low-ell polarisation from Planck (20'+10) - Jean-Loup Puget (IAS, Orsay)  
10:20 AM
CMB science case (until 12:50 PM)
10:20 AM Jérôme Martin: Inflation (20'+10)  
10:50 AM Lensing science and de-lensing (20'+10) - Anthony Challinor (University of Cambridge)  
11:20 AM --- Coffee Break ---
11:50 AM Galaxy clusters + synergy with eRosita (20'+10) - Rashid Sunyaev  
12:20 PM Neutrino physics (20'+10) - Julien Lesgourgues (Institute for Theoretical Particle Physics and Cosmology Aachen University)  
8:30 AM
M5 Proposal and mission design (until 9:30 AM)
8:30 AM Quijote (15'+5') - Jose-Alberto Rubino-Martin (Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias)  
8:50 AM C-BASS (15'+5') - Mike Jones (The University of Manchester)  
9:10 AM Mathieu Remazeilles (on behalf of Clive Dickinson). : Foreground emissions (15'+5) - Mathieu Remazeilles (University of Manchester)  
9:30 AM
M5 Proposal and mission design (until 11:00 AM)
9:30 AM Report from the ESA CDF study (15'+5) - Jacques Delabrouille (CNRS, Laboratoire APC, Paris)  
9:50 AM The M5 concept: COrE/LiteCORE design and options (20'+5) - Paolo de Bernardis (University of Rome La Sapienza)  
10:15 AM Open discussion on the M5 proposal and options (20'+5)  
10:40 AM A KIDs focal plane for COrE/LiteCORE (15'+5') - Martino Calvo (Institut Neel, Grenoble)  
11:00 AM --- Coffee Break ---
11:30 AM
US contribution (until 12:50 PM)
11:30 AM US Contributions and MO (10') - Shaul Hanany (University of Minnesota/Twin Cities)  
11:40 AM Focal plane with horn coupled multi-chroic TES (20') - Joel Ullom (NIST (US))  
12:00 PM Focal plane with phased arrays TES (20') - Roger O'Brient (NASA)  
12:20 PM Focal plane with Sinuous Antenna, lens coupled (20') - John Carlstrom (The University of Chicago)  
12:40 PM High Performance Computing Resources (10') - Julian Borrill (Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory)  
9:00 AM
Parallel: Focal plane and Payload - Shaul Hanany (University of Minnesota/Twin Cities) Paolo de Bernardis (University of Rome La Sapienza) (until 12:30 PM) (40/S2-D01 - Salle Dirac)
9:00 AM Target sensitivity focal plane tradeoffs and requirements - Paolo de Bernardis (University of Rome La Sapienza) Michel Piat (APC, Paris)  
9:20 AM Telescope: baseline design - Shaul Hanany (University of Minnesota/Twin Cities) Neil A. Trappe (NIU, Maynooth, Ireland)  
9:40 AM Discussion on telescope baseline  
9:55 AM KIDs detectors + developments in France - Martino Calvo (Institut Neel, Grenoble)  
10:15 AM KIDs developments in Italy - Paolo de Bernardis (University of Rome La Sapienza)  
10:25 AM CEB developments - Leonid Kuzmin (Chalmers, Gothenburg, Sweden)  
10:35 AM Large‐area TES developments in Italy - Flavio Gatti (University and INFN of Genova)  
10:45 AM Detectors coupling - Giampaolo Pisano (Cardiff University, UK)  
11:05 AM Discussion on sensors technology  
11:35 AM --- Coffee Break ---
11:55 AM Readout technology in the US - Joel Ullom (NIST (US))  
12:10 PM Readout technology in France - Martino Calvo (Institut Neel, Grenoble) Damien Prele (APC, Paris, France)  
12:20 PM Discussion on sensors/readout technology end of session  
9:00 AM
Parallel: Science and simulations (until 12:30 PM) (40/S2-C01 - Salle Curie)
9:00 AM Constraints on Inflation for various missions - Sebastian Clesse (Institute is Aachen)  
9:15 AM Cosmology from various missions - Eleonora Di Valentino (Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris)  
9:30 AM Constraints on Cosmology - Alessandro Melchiorri  
9:45 AM Galaxy clusters - Jean-Baptiste Melin (CEA)  
10:00 AM Large Scale Structures - Jim Bartlett (APC, Paris)  
10:20 AM Velocity effects - Carlo Burigana (INAF, Bologna)  
10:35 AM Constraining local non-Gaussianity with the CIB - Vincent Desjacques  
10:50 AM Foregrounds - Anthony Banday (IRAP, Toulouse) Mathieu Remazeilles (University of Manchester)  
10:50 AM Inflation - Martin Bucher Univ Paris 7/CNRS Fabio Finelli (INAF, Bologna)  
10:50 AM Lensing/clusters/LSS - Anthony Challinor (University of Cambridge) Jim Bartlett (APC, Paris) Jean-Baptiste Melin (CEA)  
10:50 AM Systematics - Paolo Natoli (University of Ferrara)   (40/S2-B01 - Salle Bohr)
9:00 AM
Reports from splinter sessions and discussion (until 12:00 PM)
9:00 AM Science report - Eiichiro Komatsu (Max-Planck-Institute for Astrophysics, Garching)  
9:30 AM Simulations report - Paolo Natoli (University of Ferrara)  
10:00 AM Foregrounds report - Anthony Banday (IRAP, Toulouse)  
10:30 AM --- Coffee Break ---
11:00 AM Focal plane instrument report - Paolo de Bernardis (University of Rome La Sapienza) Shaul Hanany (University of Minnesota/Twin Cities)  
11:30 AM Payload report - Bruno Maffei (Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale) Marco Bersanelli (Professor of Astronomy and Astrophysics)  
PM
12:50 PM --- Lunch ---
2:00 PM
Beyond the primary CMB (until 4:00 PM)
2:00 PM Spectral-spatial distortions (15'+5) - Jens Chluba (University of Manchester)  
2:20 PM Galactic magnetic fields (15'+5) - François Boulanger (Université Paris Sud, Orsay, France)  
2:40 PM Extragalactic sources (15'+5) - Gianfranco de Zotti (INAF Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova)  
3:00 PM Cross-correlation science and cosmic velocity flows(20'+10') - Simone Ferraro (Berkeley)  
3:30 PM Remotely: Synergy with LSS probes (20'+10') - Thomas Kitching  
4:00 PM
The suborbital roadmap (until 5:10 PM)
4:00 PM The CMB-S3 landscape (15'+5) - Clem Pryke (Dept. of Physics. The University of Minnesota, Minneapolis)  
4:20 PM Balloons (15'+5) - William Jones (Princeton University)  
4:40 PM CMB-S4 (20'+10) - John Carlstrom (The University of Chicago)  
5:10 PM --- Coffee Break ---
5:30 PM
Space missions proposals (until 7:10 PM)
5:30 PM Progress with LiteBIRD (20'+10') - Masashi Hazumi (KEK-IPNS)  
6:00 PM Remotely by phone : CMB polarization with PIXIE (20'+10') - Dr Alan Kogut (NASA)  
6:30 PM Round table: moderated by Marco Bersanelli and François Bouchet - What next? science objectives and required observations: Objective: Open discussion of what are the strengths and weaknesses of possible future experiments, complementarity, what is our target science for the M5 proposal and what is the best strategy to get it - Marco Bersanelli (Professor of Astronomy and Astrophysics)  
8:00 PM
Gala Dinner (until 10:00 PM)
12:50 PM --- Lunch ---
2:00 PM
Japanese status (until 3:00 PM)
2:00 PM Japanese plans w.r.t. international collaboration - Masashi Hazumi (KEK)  
2:30 PM Discussion : implications for the M5 proposal  
3:00 PM
Data analysis, simulations, systematics and calibration (until 4:20 PM)
3:00 PM The data analysis challenge (15'+5) - Julian Borrill (Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory)  
3:20 PM Simulation plans (15'+5') - Paolo Natoli (University of Ferrara)  
3:40 PM Planck HFI Systematics and strategy for COrE (15'+5') - Guillaume Patanchon (Université Paris Diderot)  
4:00 PM Calibration and testing (15'+5') - Marco Bersanelli (University of Milano, Italy)  
4:20 PM --- Coffee Break ---
4:50 PM
CERN contribution (until 6:10 PM)
4:50 PM Exploring fundamental physics with gravitational waves" - Gian Giudice (CERN)  
5:20 PM Models of Inflation and Particle Physics - Jonathan R. Ellis (University of London (GB))  
5:50 PM CERN Technology and experimental expertise - Enrico Chesta (CERN)  
6:10 PM
Discussion and conclusion of plenary meeting (until 6:50 PM)
6:10 PM Plans for parallel sessions (20')  
6:30 PM Concluding remarks (15'+5') - Reno Mandolesi (Bologna)  
12:30 PM --- Lunch ---
1:30 PM
Parallel: Focal plane and Payload (until 4:40 PM) (40/S2-D01 - Salle Dirac)
1:30 PM Payload Requirements and Tradeoffs - Bruno Maffei (Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale)  
1:40 PM Outcome of CDF study - Paolo de Bernardis (University of Rome La Sapienza)  
1:55 PM Scan strategy constraints - Jacques Delabrouille (CNRS, Laboratoire APC, Paris)  
2:05 PM Cooling Chain - Gerard VERMEULEN (Institut Neel (CNRS)) Yan Pennec (Air Liquide, France)  
2:15 PM Remotely : Planck cryochain heritage: alternative 15-20K stage and lessons learned - Gianluca Morgante (IASF/INAF Bologna, Italy)  
2:25 PM Discussion on payload/thermal  
2:40 PM --- Coffee Break ---
3:00 PM GRASP simulations and beam testing - Fabrizio Villa (IASF/INAF Bologna, Italy) Maura Sandri (IASF/INAF Bologna, Italy)  
3:10 PM Telescope Technology TBD  
3:20 PM Discussion on telescope  
3:35 PM Guidelines for e2e Calibration plan - Marco Marco Bersanelli (Professor of Astronomy and Astrophysics)  
3:45 PM Impact on science: Handling systematics budget - Daniele Mennella (University of Milano, Italy)  
3:55 PM Instrument-level calibration: Planck HFI experience TBD  
4:05 PM Optical testing - Bruno Maffei (Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale)  
4:15 PM Discussion on calibration  
4:30 PM End of Session - Visit to LHC  
1:30 PM
Parallel: Science and simulations (until 4:40 PM) (40/S2-C01 - Salle Curie)
1:30 PM PSM simulations - Jacques Delabrouille (CNRS, Laboratoire APC, Paris)  
1:40 PM Remotely : component separation with NILC - Soumen Basak  
1:50 PM Component separation with PILC - Patricio Vielva  
2:00 PM Component separation with COMMANDER - Mathieu Remazeilles (University of Manchester)  
2:10 PM Carlos Hervias: component separation with CCA  
2:20 PM Impact of zodiacal light - Ken Ganga (APC, Paris)  
2:30 PM Forecasting statistical and systematic uncertaibtes of parametric component separation - Josquin Errand  
2:40 PM --- Coffee break ---
3:00 PM Bandpass mismatch correction - Guillaume Patanchon (Université Paris Diderot)  
3:10 PM Mapping polarization with COrE - Linda Polastri (Università di Ferrara and INFN)  
3:20 PM Low-frequency noise - Martin Bucher Univ Paris 7/CNRS  
3:30 PM Beam mismatch correction - Ranajoy Banerji  
3:40 PM QuickPol (remotely) - Eric Hivon  
4:40 PM
First group walks to CERN main reception to meet the guides (until 5:00 PM)
5:00 PM
Visit of CERN (until 6:00 PM) (3162/R-D01 - ATLAS Visitor Centre)
5:40 PM
Second group walks to CERN main reception to meet the guides (until 6:00 PM)
6:00 PM
Visit of CERN (until 7:00 PM) (3162/R-D01 - ATLAS Visitor Centre)
12:00 PM
Organization: (splinter) (until 1:00 PM)
1:00 PM --- Lunch ---
2:00 PM
Discussion of plans (plenary) (until 4:00 PM)