2nd Muon Community Meeting
Zoom
• What is needed as input for next Strategy Update?
– What will be objections to the muon collider concept?
– What do we need to support to be scientifically sound?
– What do we need to have ready for the test facilities?
– And the other R&D programme?
• Probably should think in terms of scope from the beginning: for each R&D item, define required level => Initial proposal:
- no work needed;
- concept, basic parameters;
- lattice, reasonable basic performance specifications;
- lattice with tolerances, advanced performance specifications;
- conceptual design;
- engineering design;
- model, test of specific parameters;
- prototype.
Charge for this Second Muon Community Meeting:
During the first community meeting we identified a set of challenges in the delivery of the muon collider. The goal now is to confirm those challenges and develop them into a prioritised and resource loaded R&D list.
In particular:
- Identify the R&D that has to be carried out before the next ESSU-PP to scientifically justify the investment into a full CDR for the muon collider and the corresponding demonstration programme.
- Identify the main components of the demonstration programme together with the corresponding preparatory work.
- Realistic but ambitious targets for the performance goals of the different collider systems.
Conveners of the 11 working groups (note that we are in the process of enhancing the working group conveners, so the following is subject to change: as of 15/06/21):
Radio-Frequency (RF): Alexej Grudiev (CERN), Jean-Pierre Delahaye (CERN retiree), Derun Li (LBNL), Akira Yamamoto (KEK).
Magnets: Lionel Quettier (CEA), Toru Ogitsu (KEK), Soren Prestemon (LBNL), Sasha Zlobin (FNAL), Emanuela Barzi (FNAL).
High-Energy Complex (HEC): Antoine Chance (CEA), J. Scott Berg (BNL), Alex Bogacz (JLAB), Christian Carli (CERN), Angeles Faus-Golfe (IJCLab), Eliana Gianfelice-Wendt (FNAL), Shinji Machida (RAL).
Muon Production and Cooling (MPC): Chris Rogers (RAL), Marco Calviani (CERN), Chris Densham (RAL), Diktys Stratakis (FNAL), Akira Sato (Osaka University), Katsuya Yonehara (FNAL).
Proton Complex (PC): Simone Gilardoni (CERN), Hannes Bartosik (CERN), Frank Gerigk (CERN), Natalia Milas (ESS).
Beam Dynamics (BD): Elias Metral (CERN), Tor Raubenheimer (SLAC and Stanford University), Rob Ryne (LBNL).
Radiation Protection (RP): Claudia Ahdida (CERN).
Parameters, Power and Cost (PPC): Daniel Schulte (CERN), Mark Palmer (BNL), Philippe Lebrun (CERN retiree and ESI), Mike Seidel (PSI), Vladimir Shiltsev (FNAL), Jingyu Tang (IHEP).
Machine Detector Interface (MDI): Donatella Lucchesi (University of Padova and INFN), Christian Carli (CERN), Anton Lechner (CERN), Nicolai Mokhov (FNAL), Nadia Pastrone (INFN), Sergo R Jindariani (FNAL).
Synergy: Kenneth Long (Imperial College), Roger Ruber (Uppsala University), Koichiro Shimomura (KEK).
Test Facility (TF): Roberto Losito (CERN), Alan Bross (FNAL), Tord Ekelof (Uppsala University).
=> Structure of the 3-day meeting:
- July 12: plenary introduction, parallel working groups finalise list of required R&D
- July 13: plenary: working groups present lists of required R&D and resource estimates
- July 14: plenary: first prioritised list of R&D items, opportunity to express interest


-
-
14:00
→
14:30
Plenary session (in same zoom room)
July 12: plenary introduction, parallel working groups finalise list of required R&D
Convener: Chris Rogers (STFC)-
14:00
Update on the LDG process 25mSpeaker: Daniel Schulte (CERN)
- 14:25
-
14:00
-
14:30
→
18:00
BD (Beam Dynamics)
-
14:30
Joint session with High Energy Complex (HEC) in the BD room 1h
-
16:00
Joint discussion with Proton complex in Beam dynamics room 30m
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
18:00
HEC (High-Energy Complex)
-
14:30
Joint session with Beam Dynamics (BD) in the BD room 1h
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
18:00
MDI (Machine Detector Interface)
-
14:30
Common discussion on tasks and needed resources 1hSpeakers: Anton Lechner (CERN), Christian Carli (CERN), Donatella Lucchesi, Nadia Pastrone (INFN Torino (IT)), Nikolai Mokhov (Fermi National Accelerator Lab. (US))
-
15:30
Joint session with High Energy Complex 1h
-
16:30
Joint session with Radiation Protection on Neutrino Radiation Mitigation 1h
-
17:30
Final summary 30m
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
19:00
MPC (Muon Production and Cooling)
-
14:30
Target Test facility at ESS 20mSpeaker: Tord Johan Carl Ekelof (Uppsala University (SE))
-
14:50
Test Facility - possible time lines 10mSpeaker: Roberto Losito (CERN)
-
15:00
Test facility - target chamber and chicane layout 20mSpeaker: Rui Franqueira Ximenes (CERN)
-
15:20
Test facility - transfer line from PS 20mSpeaker: Chiara Bracco (CERN)
-
15:40
Test facility - collimation and cooling 20mSpeaker: Chris Rogers (STFC)
-
16:00
Discussion of target test facility 10m
-
16:10
Overview of target baseline 20mSpeaker: Kirk McDonald (Princeton University)
-
16:30
Pion yield simulations 20mSpeaker: John James Back (University of Warwick (GB))
-
16:50
Horn options 20mSpeaker: Katsuya Yonehara (Fermilab)
-
17:10
Break 20m
- 17:30
- 17:50
-
18:10
Review of final cooling options 20m
-
18:30
Discussion 30m
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
19:00
Magnets
- 14:30
- 14:50
- 15:00
-
15:10
High frequency HTS magnet 10mSpeaker: Vladimir Shiltsev (Fermilab)
- 15:20
-
15:30
Stress management for High Energy Muon Collider's Storage Ring and IR Magnets 10mSpeaker: emanuela barzi (Fermilab)
-
15:40
Discussion about technical issues and R&D timelines 1h 20m
-
17:00
Possible synergies and collaborators 30m
-
14:30
→
18:00
PC (Proton Complex)
-
14:30
Introduction 15m
-
14:45
ESS Status and Prospects 20m
-
15:05
Discussion 55m
-
16:00
Joint discussion with Beam Dynamics in Beam Dynamics Room 35m
-
16:35
Discussion 1h 25m
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
18:00
PPC (Parameters, Power and Cost)
-
14:30
Schedule Considerations 20mSpeaker: Daniel Schulte (CERN)
-
14:50
An Overview of the MC Technology Drivers 20mSpeaker: Mark Palmer (BNL)
-
15:10
Discussion on Technology Drivers 20mSpeaker: Philippe Lebrun
- 15:30
-
15:50
Cost Drivers 20m
-
16:10
Discussion on Scenarios 1h
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
18:00
RF (Radio-Frequency)
-
14:30
Discussion on SRF R&D work packages 1h 30mSpeakers: Akira Yamamoto (High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (JP)), Akira Yamamoto (High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (JP))
-
16:00
Break 30m
-
16:30
Discussion on NRF R&D work packages 1h 30mSpeaker: Derun Li (LBNL)
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
18:00
Synergy
-
14:30
Synergies in high power and muon beam R&D in China 20mSpeaker: Jingyu Tang (Institute of High Energy Physics, CAS)
-
14:50
The COMET and PRISM programmes and synergies with muon collider programme 20mSpeaker: Akira Sato (Osaka University)
-
15:10
Target studies for COMET and in the J-PARC Materials and Life Science Facility 20mSpeaker: Prof. Shunsake Makimura (KEK)
-
15:30
The potential to deliver high quality muon beams could enhance the capabilities of muon sources such as those at PSI, ISIS and J-PARC. 20mSpeaker: Prof. Koichiro Shimomura (KEK)
-
15:50
Synergies in the Korean high-power accelerator programme (TBC) 20mSpeaker: Prof. Juhahn Lee (Rare Isotope Science Project)
-
14:30
-
14:30
→
16:10
Test Facility (TF) Joint with Muon Production and Cooling in Muon Production and Cooling Room
-
16:30
→
18:00
RP (Radiation Protection) joint session w MDI and HEC
-
16:30
Plans for a refined dose model 30mSpeaker: Claudia Ahdida
-
17:00
First considerations for a surface map 30mSpeaker: Youri Robert (CERN)
-
17:30
Discussion 30m
-
16:30
-
14:00
→
14:30
-
-
14:00
→
15:45
Plenary session (in same zoom room)
July 13: plenary: working groups present lists of required R&D and resource estimates
Convener: Daniel Schulte (CERN)-
14:00
RF Summary 15mSpeakers: Akira Yamamoto (High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (JP)), Akira Yamamoto (High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (JP)), Alexej Grudiev (CERN), Derun Li (LBNL), Jean-Pierre Delahaye
-
14:15
Magnets Summary 15mSpeakers: Alexander Zlobin (Fermilab), Emanuela Barzi (Fermilab), Lionel Quettier, Soren Prestemon, Toru Ogitsu, emanuela barzi (Fermilab)
-
14:30
High Energy Complex Summary 15mSpeakers: Angeles Faus-Golfe (IJClab IN2P3 CNRS-Université Paris-Saclay (FR)), Antoine Chance (CEA Irfu), Christian Carli (CERN), Eliana Gianfelice-Wendt, J. Scott Berg (Brookhaven National Laboratory), S. Alex Bogacz (Jefferson Lab), Shinji Machida (STFC/RAL)
-
14:45
Test facility 15mSpeakers: Alan Bross (Fermilab), Roberto Losito (CERN), Tord Johan Carl Ekelof (Uppsala University (SE))
-
15:00
Proton Complex 15mSpeakers: Frank Gerigk (CERN), Hannes Bartosik (CERN), Natalia Milas (P), Simone Gilardoni (CERN)
-
15:15
Discussion 30m
-
14:00
-
15:45
→
16:15
Coffee break 30m
-
16:15
→
18:00
Plenary session (in same zoom room)Convener: Daniel Schulte (CERN)
-
16:15
Beam Dynamics Summary 15mSpeakers: Elias Metral (CERN), Robert Ryne, Tor Raubenheimer (SLAC), Tor Raubenheimer (SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory (US))
-
16:30
Radiation Protection Summary 15mSpeaker: Claudia Ahdida
-
16:45
Muon Production and Cooling Summary 15mSpeakers: Akira Sato (Osaka University), Chris Densham (STFC Rutherford Appleton Laboratory), Chris Rogers (STFC), Diktys Stratakis (Fermilab), Katsuya Yonehara (Fermilab), Marco Calviani (CERN)
-
17:00
Machine Detector Interface Summary 15mSpeakers: Anton Lechner (CERN), Christian Carli (CERN), Donatella Lucchesi, Donatella Lucchesi (Universita e INFN, Padova (IT)), Nadia Pastrone (Universita e INFN Torino (IT)), Nikolai Mokhov (Fermi National Accelerator Lab. (US)), Sergo Jindariani (Fermi National Accelerator Lab. (US))
-
17:15
Synergy Summary 15mSpeakers: Kenneth Long (CERN), Kenneth Richard Long (Imperial College (GB)), Koichiro Shimomura (KEK), Roger Ruber (Uppsala University (SE))
-
17:30
Discussion 30m
-
16:15
-
14:00
→
15:45
-
-
14:00
→
15:45
Plenary session (in same zoom room)
July 14: plenary: first prioritised list of R&D items, opportunity to express interest
Convener: Daniel Schulte (CERN)- 14:00
-
14:30
Horizon Europe planning 30mSpeakers: Daniel Schulte (CERN), Roberto Losito (CERN)
-
15:00
Test facility work package plan 45mSpeakers: Marco Calviani (CERN), Roberto Losito (CERN), Tord Johan Carl Ekelof (Uppsala University (SE))
-
15:45
→
16:15
Coffee break 30m
-
16:15
→
18:00
Plenary session (in same zoom room)Convener: Daniel Schulte (CERN)
-
16:15
Hardware work package plan 45mSpeakers: Alexej Grudiev (CERN), Philippe Lebrun (European Scientific Institute (FR)), Toru Ogitsu
-
17:00
Conceptual design work package plan 45mSpeakers: Angeles Faus-Golfe (IJClab IN2P3 CNRS-Université Paris-Saclay (FR)), Angeles Faus-Golfe (Instituto de Fisica Corpuscular (IFIC) UV-CSIC), Antoine Chance (CEA Irfu), Chris Rogers (STFC), Christian Carli (CERN), Simone Gilardoni (CERN)
-
17:45
Discussion 15m
-
16:15
-
14:00
→
15:45